Showing posts with label religion and immigration. Show all posts
Showing posts with label religion and immigration. Show all posts

The Fence: Mainline Protestants and Immigration Sixty Years Ago

Today's guest post comes from Nicholas T. Pruitt, a Visiting Instructor in History at Eastern Nazarene College. Pruitt recently completed a dissertation titled "Open Hearts, Closed Doors: Native Protestants, Pluralism, and the 'Foreigner' in America, 1924-1965."

Before there was talk of a wall, there was The Fence. First circulated in 1956, The Fence was a pamphlet that demonstrated sharp divisions among Americans over immigration policy. I first encountered this booklet while researching for my dissertation on white Protestant responses to immigration between 1924 and 1965. As I sifted through material from the Presbyterian Historical Archives, I came to realize that the history surrounding The Fence speaks volumes about midcentury American society and the position of white Protestants who sponsored its publication.

Many mainline Protestant leaders contributed to the public conversation surrounding the McCarran-Walter Act of 1952, a bill that aimed to revamp the nation’s immigration system. While it ended Japanese exclusion, its critics pointed out that the legislation was still premised on unevenly distributed quotas based on national origins and other forms of discrimination. Congress eventually passed the bill sponsored by Nevada Senator Pat McCarran and Pennsylvania Congressman Francis Walter, but only after overriding Harry Truman’s veto. Most mainline Protestant denominations opposed the legislation, drawing upon a mix of postwar internationalism, social gospel ideals, and common concern for home missions. While the bill was being considered, the National Council of Churches (NCC) passed a statement in March 1952 calling for Congress to reform the quota system and demanding that the United States assume its global responsibilities and aid refugees. It is striking that in Truman’s veto message of McCarran-Walter, he even invoked the social gospel rhetoric of his Protestant contemporaries, claiming that the law “repudiates our basic religious concepts, our belief in the brotherhood of man.” Following its passage, the mainline periodical Christian Century questioned the law and had to fend off an angry rebuttal by McCarran, and Methodist Bishop G. Bromley Oxnam even had to answer for his criticism of the legislation before the House Un-American Activities Committee, on which Walter served, in 1953.


Following the bill’s passage, mainline Protestant groups continued to voice their concerns over an immigration system predicated on national origins, often through the medium of pamphlets. The Fence was one such effort to educate constituents of the McCarran-Walter Act’s shortcomings. The Fence was first published in 1956 and then reprinted and expanded in 1959 in time for World Refugee Year. By that year, sponsors had circulated 85,000 copies. The tract itself follows a conversation between a boy, who represented European refugees fleeing communism, and a police officer guarding a gate into the United States. The officer assures the boy that America is taking proper action to help, but the boy then produces a copy of the McCarran-Walter Act and tries to explain its flaws. At this point, an American lawyer comes to the boy’s defense. He points out that the law favors British, Irish, and German immigrants and refugees, while shunning others from eastern and southern Europe, Asia, and Africa. The officer eventually reconsiders his views, coming to the conclusion, “Sounds un-American to me.” In sum, The Fence contends that McCarran-Walter promotes racial discrimination, does not adequately address the refugee crisis, and handicaps foreign policy, and that immigrants are a boon to labor, are law-abiding, and overall “strengthen the nation.” Historian Robert Fleegler suggests in Ellis Island Nation that the pamphlet draws upon the idea of “contributionism,” or the notion coming into vogue by the 1950s that America is a nation of immigrants.

The Fence was made available at a time when mainline Protestants frequently teamed up with their Jewish and Catholic counterparts and other civic organizations, forming a broad consensus on various sociopolitical issues. As Kevin Schultz has shown in Tri-Faith America, midcentury Americans were reconsidering the boundaries of the nation’s religious identity and beginning to accept a Judeo-Christian pluralism, though, as I argue in my dissertation, even progressive mainliners still flirted occasionally with a Protestant vision for the nation. Yet, the diversity of organizations that signed off on The Fence is striking. A cross section of mainline Protestant denominations sponsored the tract, in addition to the NCC’s United Church Women and the Young Women’s Christian Association. Moreover, Protestant groups promoted the pamphlet alongside the American Jewish Committee, National Council of Jewish Women, and National Urban League, while also joining forces with a couple of labor groups. Such a spirit of unity and cooperation, however, should not be seen as representative of mainline American Protestantism as a whole. While many local church councils and societies joined in the chorus of those criticizing the McCarran-Walter Act, more conservative Protestants resented their denominations’ views.

The liberal positions behind The Fence invited varied opinions on immigration and invoked a lingering nativism among some Protestant Americans. One Presbyterian from Pennsylvania wrote his denomination criticizing its support of the “clever, although elemental piece of propaganda.” He believed the Presbyterian Church in the U.S.A. used the pamphlet “without any consultation of the church membership” and suggested The Fence was “part of an under cover drive . . . to complete a latter-day influx by peoples with widely divergent viewpoints to those of the earlier immigrants who made America what it is today." The letter demonstrates a divide between liberal and conservative Protestants within the same denomination, something Elesha Coffman addresses in her work, and tension between two competing interpretations of national identity.

To help with promotion, a form for ordering The Fence employed the logic often seen in the appeals of charitable organizations: take 20 minutes to read the pamphlet and write your congressman, and thus make a difference. By taking action, the reader would help open up a “hole in the fence – a gate to opportunity – a new life in the free world for an immigrant.” Some white Protestants believed such a “gate” should be made available, and on an equal basis for all immigrants and refugees; these more liberal Protestants had grown comfortable with a limited form of pluralism. Conservative church members, however, maintained another vision for the nation, one that clung to the idea that America was a Protestant Christian nation where one could easily identify the insiders from the outsiders. Whether due to fences, creeds, or iron curtains, Americans were hard pressed to find the right words for consensus during the postwar period.
spacer

Five Questions with Eladio Bobadilla on Immigration and Catholic History

Catherine R. Osborne (for the Cushwa Center for the Study of American Catholicism, University of Notre Dame)

Eladio Bobadilla
Eladio Bobadilla is a Ph.D. candidate in U.S. History at Duke University. His dissertation is entitled "'One People Without Borders': The Chicano Roots of the Immigrants Rights Movement, 1954-1994," and explores how Mexican-Americans, long ambivalent and even opposed to undocumented immigration, came to see themselves and the undocumented as "one people." He was awarded a 2016 Theodore M. Hesburgh Travel Grant to consult Fr. Hesburgh's papers related to his work on the Commission on Immigration and Refugee Policy. (The next grant applications will be due October 1, so start thinking of topics now!)

CO: What got you interested in this topic?

EB: My interest in this topic is largely autobiographical. Immigration is part of my story and has shaped me and my worldview since I was a child. My father was, at various points in his life, a bracero, an undocumented immigrant, a permanent resident, and a U.S. citizen. I, too, was undocumented until the age of 19. So questions about immigration—and about shifting and unstable identities—were always part of my experience. Similarly, growing up in Delano, CA, home of the farm labor movement, inspired me to ask questions about the relationship(s) between labor, immigration, capitalism, and social movements.




CO: After spending some time at the archives, what do you see as Fr. Hesburgh's relevance to your overall project?

EB: Father Hesburgh possessed a rare set of qualities that are seldom found so neatly packaged in one human being alone: he was compassionate, but he was pragmatic. He had equal measures of moral vision and political will. He was interested in social justice and in rational debate. He could get people who disagreed fundamentally with each other to sit in a room and actually listen to one another, and crucially, to compromise in fruitful ways. Father Hesburgh understood that neither pure isolationism nor fully open borders were sensible or workable positions, and he worked really hard to ensure that what ultimately became policy was both in the national interest and as humane as possible.

CO: What would you still like to know that you weren't able to answer through the Hesburgh archives?

Reagan signs the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986
EB: There is so much that archives alone cannot answer. That is why I am interested in oral history. Much of what I found in the Hesburgh archives has led me to ask new questions and to seek answers in other ways. For example, it is clear from my work at the Hesburgh archives that no one was truly happy with the outcome of the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986, and I think it’s fair to say, that just about everyone has considered it a failure in some way or another. Hispanics thought it was a racist piece of legislation. Businesses interests felt like they weren’t given enough access to labor. Conservative hard-liners thought it was too lenient and permissive. But what about the immigrants themselves, those whose status was normalized by IRCA? What did they think? Well, we don’t really find their voices in the archives. But, it seems to me, from talking to them, that they would hardly see IRCA as a failure. This piece of legislation changed millions of lives for the better, in tangible and discernible ways: they were able to finally work and live without fear, to sponsor family members—or at the very least to visit them without risking their lives on the return trip. They were able to buy homes, to start businesses. Sometimes, even the best archives cannot adequately capture the human experience. This is why I combine oral history and other methods with archival research. Often archives leave researchers with more questions than answers, but that’s not a bad thing. It’s important to know what we don’t know, so to speak, and to find other ways to answer important historical questions.

CO: What's your favorite document you found at the ND archives?

EB: One of my favorite finds in the archives at Notre Dame was an Air Force manual detailing the processing of Vietnamese refugees. Specifically, the manual outlined how to properly welcome and assist those refugees in the United States. This was an interesting find for a number of reasons. It wasn’t directly related to my research topic, but it allowed me to think—and in some ways challenged me to think—differently about immigration. The manual was a two hundred-plus page document that enthusiastically welcomed Vietnamese refugees fleeing the Vietnam War, and for me, it was a document that clearly and starkly highlighted the complicated nature of immigration policy. At the same time that American officials were trying to limit immigration from Latin America, regularly describing it as a crisis and a social problem, thousands of Vietnamese were being relocated, housed, and provided with jobs and legal status. What this reveals is that immigration has often been, more than an issue in itself, what I call a “filter issue,” one that is really a placeholder for other, broader concerns, from economic anxiety to questions about war and imperialism.

CO: This is obviously a topic with a lot of salience today -- maybe more than you could have guessed when you set out to write about it. Do you see today's American church leaders continuing their role, or is it different? Any lessons today's Catholic immigrants-rights' activists could learn from their predecessors?

EB: The Catholic Church and people of faith have a tremendous role to play today in today’s immigration debate. The debate about immigration has, in many ways, devolved into little more than an emotional shouting match. The rhetoric one hears today, even in supposedly reputable sources, is based on dangerous premises that rely less on logic and more ugly, racial undertones. It seems to me that what we’re lacking today is empathy. The dehumanization of human beings, whose humanity is often reduced to illegality, has dangerous precedents in history. This isn’t to say that immigration doesn’t have real consequences for Americans, or that the answer should be simply to open the borders, though I think in reality globalization has already done this. But the stereotypes and scapegoating that we hear in today’s immigration debates are dangerous and frightening to those of us who study history. The Church, I think, has a role in mediating these discussions, just as Father Hesburgh did in the 1980s, and in reminding people of faith there are real human beings, often poor and vulnerable, behind the heated rhetoric—and that they are here because they are desperate and poor, often because of corporate greed and inhumane trade and social policies. In other words, the church can help remind people that the problem isn’t “illegals,” but vast economic interests that create poverty and drive immigration, as well as power-hungry political forces eager to exploit people’s very economic real anxieties and cultural fears. I have been impressed, and putting aside any notion of objectivity, grateful and inspired to hear Pope Francis speak to this issue with tremendous moral clarity and courage. He has repeatedly reminded his flock and the world that human lives and human welfare should always come before profit. That is a remarkably radical and necessary message at a time when capitalist orthodoxy has sought to render compassion obsolete.
spacer

CFP Roundup: American Religion and Global Affairs

Lauren Turek
Presbyterian Conference, Chicago, 1871
Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division

I have come across several CFPs recently for conferences on topics pertaining to U.S. foreign
relations or international affairs that include specific requests for papers on religion or aspects of American religious history. I have included the full descriptions and CFPs for these opportunities that may be of interest to readers of this blog, with particularly relevant potential topic areas in bold, after the break.





The 9/11 Legacy
“History is Not Was, History Is”


Sponsored by the Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, the National September 11 Memorial & Museum, and New York University

Location/Date: National September 11 Memorial & Museum, New York City, June 15-16, 2017
CFP Deadline: April 1, 2017

Description: This conference to be held at the National September 11 Memorial & Museum on the former World Trade Center site will explore the broader legacy of 9/11. We seek panel and paper proposals – both traditional and novel, empirical and conceptual – that consider the myriad ways that the events of September 11, 2001, continue to inform the past, the present and the future: both in the United States and around the world.

This was the most globally witnessed event in history and one that led to the longest war in the history of the United States. What, then, are the legacies that ripple out from the memorial fountains here in lower Manhattan across the city, the country, and the globe? As William Faulkner observed, “History is not was, history is.” How has the event of “9/11” reverberated in our understanding of the past and in more contemporary social, political, and cultural life; in the economy, in war and peace, surveillance and security, the geopolitics of the Middle East, the refugee crisis and in the debates over identity, memory and sacred space? What historical processes might we trace – either backwards or forwards – from September 11, 2001? What news headlines can we connect to 9/11 in meaningful and instructive ways: Paris, Orlando, Istanbul, the Arab Spring, Aleppo, the death of Syrian refugee child Alan Kurdi, Edward Snowden, Russia, the 2016 U.S. presidential election, the list goes on…

We welcome proposals that consider the ways in which, to quote Mark Redfield in The Rhetoric of Terror, a “new history begins here at this calendrical ground zero.”

Topics might include (but are not limited to):


  • 9/11 and historiography
  • 9/11 and periodization
  • Memory and memorialization
  • Sacred and contested spaces
  • “America in the world”
  • The conflicts in the Middle East and South Asia
  • Acts of terror around the globe since 9/11
  • The changing face of terrorism
  • The changing face of warfare and nation-building
  • Intelligence, surveillance and counter-terrorism
  • Para-legality, states of exception and rendition
  • Nationalism, identity, “self “and “other”
  • Human rights, civil liberties and conceptions of “freedom”
  • Shifts in cultural production and representation since 9/11
  • The media, social media and the “image” of terror
  • The academy, museums and cultural institutions
  • The return of religion
  • The refugee crisis
  • Discussions of time and space; home and homeland
We especially seek interdisciplinary panel and paper proposals that draw on the intersections between these topics and themes in order to explore the ways in which they might (or might not be) traced back to, or through, 9/11. Do they have a narrative coherence shaped by the forces created that day in September? Or do they operate outside the event, as part of some other inevitable geopolitical shift that we now know only by that name-date even if that shift might have happened anyway?

We invite paper and panel proposals from scholars, practitioners, curators, graduate students and other professionals who can speak to the conference theme. Please send an abstract of no more than 300 words and CV to the conference organizers at 2017conference@911memorial.org by April 1, 2017. Panel proposals should include an additional abstract for the theme of the panel. Some financial assistance will be available to help offset the cost of attendance. Selected papers may be included in a follow-up edited volume/special edition.

Contact Info:
Dr. Andrew Hammond

Andrew W. Mellon Foundation Postdoctoral Fellow/New York University Visiting Scholar, c/o National September 11 Memorial & Museum, 200 Liberty Street, 16th Floor, New York, NY 10281, ahammond@911memorial.org/ah3880@nyu.edu


Intolerance, Discrimination and Terrorism - International Interdisciplinary Conference

Organized by the University of Gdańsk (Poland), the University of São Paulo (Brazil), and In Mind Support (Poland)

Date/Location: May 11, 2017 to May 12, 2017, University of GdaÅ„sk, Wita Stwosza Street No. 55, GdaÅ„sk, Poland
CFP Deadline: March 12, 2017

Description: Our world becomes more and more dangerous. Populists come to power, people all around the globe support xenophobic dictators, and the future of humankind goes in an unpredictable direction. Therefore, during our interdisciplinary conference we would like to discuss some crucial questions: What is the source of intolerance and discrimination in the contemporary world? Is terrorism a “natural” consequence of intolerance? How should we react to acts of intolerance, discrimination and terrorism?

We will describe the phenomena of intolerance, discrimination and terrorism in political, social, psychological, cultural and many other terms. We also want to devote considerable attention to how these phenomena are represented in artistic practices: in literature, film, theatre or visual arts.

We invite researchers representing various academic disciplines: history, politics, psychology, sociology, anthropology, philosophy, economics, law, literary studies, theatre studies, film studies, fine arts, memory studies, migration studies, consciousness studies, dream studies, gender studies, postcolonial studies, medical sciences, psychiatry, psychoanalysis, cognitive sciences etc.

Different forms of presentations are encouraged, including case studies, theoretical investigations, problem-oriented arguments, and comparative analyses.

We will be happy to hear from both experienced scholars and young academics at the start of their careers, as well as doctoral and graduate students. We also invite all persons interested in participating in the conference as listeners, without giving a presentation.

We hope that due to its interdisciplinary nature, the conference will bring many interesting observations on and discussions about intolerance, discrimination and terrorism in the past and in the present-day world.

Our repertoire of suggested topics includes but is not restricted to:

Intolerance
Intolerance and race
Intolerance and religion
Intolerance and nationalism
Intolerance and gender
Intolerance and age
Intolerance at school
Intolerance in family
Tolerance towards intolerance
Discrimination
Discrimination against elderly people
Discrimination against children
Discrimination against women
Discrimination against men
Discrimination against people with disabilities
Discrimination against the mentally ill
Discrimination against the addicts
Discrimination against the rich
Discrimination against the poor
Discrimination against animals
Economic discrimination
Genetic discrimination
Discrimination based on sexual preferences
Nationalism
Antisemitism
Racism
Colorism (discrimination based on skin color)
Sizeism (discrimination based on a person’s size)
Reverse discrimination (affirmative action, positive discrimination)
Terrorism
Political terrorism
Ideological terrorism
Religious terrorism
State terrorism
Intimate terrorism
Terrorism and fundamentalism
Terrorism and mental health
Terrorism and freedom
Cultural aspects of terrorism
Finding solutions
Anti-discrimination law
Anti-terrorist law
Human rights organizations
Humanitarian missions
Democratic education
Pro-tolerance campaigns
Literature, film and the arts
Literature and art about intolerance, discrimination and terrorism
Artists engaged in fighting intolerance, discrimination and terrorism
Artists-terrorists
Artists as victims of discrimination
Literature and art engaged in ideologies
Terrorism in the media

Please submit abstracts (no longer than 300 words) of your proposed 20-minute presentations, together with a short biographical note, by 12 March 2017 to:  intolerance2017@gmail.com

Contact Info:
Prof. Wojciech Owczarski

Contact Email:
wowczarski1@tlen.pl
URL:
http://intoleranceterrorism.ug.edu.pl/


Panel Call for Papers for American Academy of Religion Annual Meeting: Global Catholic Media: Between the Intimate and Imperial


Panel co-organizers: Dr. Marc Roscoe Loustau (Catholics & Cultures Fellow and Visiting Lecturer, College of the Holy Cross, Worcester, MA) and Dr. Eric Hoenes del Pinal (Assistant Professor, Dept. of Religious Studies, University of North Carolina at Charlotte)

Date/Location: November 18-21, 2017, Boston, MA

Overview: Over the past decade, research on Pentecostal/Charismatic Christian communities have made major contributions to the study of media, religion, and subjectivity. Emphasizing concepts such as “aesthetic formations,” “sensational forms,” “habitus,” and “orientation,” this literature has illuminated how mass mediate communication technologies including film, television, and radio contribute to the processes of self-transformation that allow Protestant Christian imaginaries to extend across subjects’ spheres of activity and lifetimes. Significantly less attention, however, has been paid to the equally vibrant field of Catholic media. What might attention to how specific communities of Catholics engaging in the production and consumption of self-consciously Catholic media spheres reveal?

This panel proposes that thick ethnographic descriptions of collective engagements with global Catholic media will illuminate how the Church negotiates its conflicting tendencies towards the imperial and the intimate. The Catholic Church’s aspiration to unity and universality imply that its institutional reach aspires to be imperial, ideally covering all humanity. Yet likewise its claim to apostolic succession implies that this imperial aspiration is of necessity carried out through intimate encounters between subjects. How then are the imperial and the intimate reconciled? How is the shift in scales between the institutional and the intersubjective achieved and experienced? And how might a focus on mediation help us better understand how these two dimensions come together in the lives of practicing Catholics?

We invite papers that look to experience-near, ethnographically- and/or biographically-rich accounts of lives and intimate relationships as potential starting points for examining the relevance of religious media to human experience, and which consider the following questions: How do individuals plumb the possibilities offered by Catholic media to find a workable balance between ambivalent attractions to domestic ties (the intimate) and global aspirations (the imperial)? What insights about Catholicism as an institution might we gain by examining how media circulates among communities of Catholics? What can theories of media consumption help us understand about Catholic subjectivities? How might the production and consumption of Catholic media help subjects shape the scope their aspirations? How do Catholic media intensify subjects’ awareness of moral or experiential paradoxes inherent in the practice of Catholicism? How do the producers of Catholic media, which is linguistically, if not also culturally, specific, reconcile that specificity with the concept of a “global Catholic Church”? Finally, how does the shared project of creating a mass mediated Catholic imaginary, also work to help individuals and communities negotiate other, perhaps less visible, aspirations and fears in the intimate relationships between human and divine beings?

Please send abstracts (250 words max.) of proposed papers to Marc Roscoe Loustau (mloustau706@gmail.com) and Eric Heones at (ehoenes@uncc.edu) ASAP. If you have questions, please email the organizers in advance. Circulate the CFP widely at your discretion.


2017 Power and Struggle Conference (Graduate Student Conference)

Sponsors: The Department of History at The University of Alabama 

Date/Location: September 22-23, 2017, University of Alabama
CFP Deadline: April 25, 2017

Overview: The Department of History at The University of Alabama is pleased to announce its Ninth Annual Graduate Student Conference on Power and Struggle, to be held at the UA campus on September 22-23, 2017. The conference will feature a keynote banquet at the Alabama Museum of Natural History by Professor Kate Brown, a Professor of History at the University of Maryland, Baltimore County.  Professor Brown has published widely on the subjects of environmental history and European and American history. She is the author of several acclaimed books, including A Biography of No Place: From Ethnic Borderland to Soviet Heartland (2004) and Plutopia: Nuclear Families in Atomic Cities and the Great Soviet and American Plutonium Disasters (2013). Her latest book is Dispatches from Dystopia: Histories of Places Not Yet Forgotten (2015). We are honored to have Dr. Brown as our keynote speaker.

Our conference encourages graduate students to submit proposals that engage the conference theme by examining power relations in all historical fields and time periods. The theme addresses new approaches of historical analysis that focus on the relationship between struggle and power, especially people who struggled to break, transform, or reclaim the boundaries constructed by those in power. The Conference seeks proposals employing innovative approaches, interdisciplinary methods, comparative perspectives, and multi-archival research bases. At the conclusion of the Conference, one presenter will earn recognition as the recipient of the Best Paper Prize. The University of Alabama’s graduate history journal, the Southern Historian, is also sponsoring an award for the Best Paper in Southern History. 

The GHA Conference seeks submissions concerning, but not limited to, the following topics:

Power in institutions, society, and religion
Struggle in cultural expression, social relationships, and belief systems
Power in discourse on gender, race, and class
Struggle against labels in nationalism, ethnicity, sub-culture, or sexual identity
Power in traditional structures such as politics, diplomacy, imperialism, and war
Struggle in resistance such as crime, protest, liberation, and revolution 

Single papers should include a 300-word abstract and a one-page CV of the presenter. Full-panel proposals will be accepted.  All submissions should be sent in Word format via email to the committee using ghaconference@gmail.com. 

The deadline for proposal submission is April 25, 2017. Final papers should be submitted to commentators by September 1, 2017.  For more information please email the committee at ghaconference@gmail.com.

Contact Info: 
University of Alabama 2017 Power and Struggle Conference Committe Chair, Sarah Craddock 
or

spacer