Showing posts with label Miles Adam Park's posts. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Miles Adam Park's posts. Show all posts

Know Your Archives: The YMCA and Historiographic Potential

by Adam Park


Special thanks to Ryan Bean, Reference and Outreach Archivist at the University of Minnesota's Kautz Family YMCA Archives, for providing insight for this post. He can be contacted here: beanx029@umn.edu. 



Though seasonally entombed by a savage Minneapolis chill, it's true, the University of Minnesota Libraries house a repository of sources with impactful significance for American religious historiography. The Kautz Family YMCA Archives are particularly promising. Well beyond issues in Christian fitness, the Y holdings (and the U of M Archives and Special Collections more broadly) are fecund with research potential. And so, along with the fried cheese curds and cold lager, here's why it might be worth your trip.

In addition to the Y materials, potentially relevant contents at the U of M Archives and Special Collections include: the history of technology, children's literature, African American literature, immigration history, early colonial contact, architectural history, social welfare history, GLBT history, and upper-midwest Jewish history.

But, taking this moment to indulge a predicable pop culture allusion, it's so much fun to study at the YMCA. They have everything. Like an East India Company, though less interested in spices and textiles than bodies and "character," the YMCA is a thoroughly established global, economic, political, and colonial enterprise; and it has been for a long time. Best of all, the Y has kept good record of itself, and the records speak to a variety of fresh historiographic topics. Here are a few academic areas where we see possibility for fruitful inquiry and expansion.

1) Religion and war. As Jonathan Ebel remarked in 2010, "studies of America's wars tend to ignore religion" and "studies of American religion tend to ignore war." To fill this historiographic lull, we can look to the Y. For where there was war, so too was there the YMCA. The YMCA aided the US Armed Forces in a variety of times and places--the Civil War, the Spanish-American War, WWI & II, at international ports and bases, and in the Panama Canal Zone. Conversely, where there was peace, so too was there the YMCA. The YMCA also assisted America's standing armies in their times of leisure. Sum, the YMCA and the Armed Forces have a seasoned rapport.

2) Religion and empire. As most of you know, the Y is a substantive global venture. Africa to Yugoslavia, in alphabetical order. But the details and extent of the YMCA's global impact remain somewhat unexplored. Pick a country. Any country, really. The Y's Men International, for example, is going very strong in Asia. And for them with academic interests in the Global South, I suspect that the Y is a significant player. "More than just a gym." Tantamount to the UN, the Peace Corps, and Rotary International. Brokering Americanisms. Spreading Christianisms. Institutionally modifying the world in a variety of certain ways. Even Antarctica.

3) Secularism. Throughout the 20th century, the "C" in YMCA has been a topic of conversation among Y leaders. The Y's Journal of Physical of Education and The Intercollegian are peppered with such talk. The Y's many programs in colleges and schools, particularly, were cause for greater consideration; it was a question of how much "religion" to vociferously proclaim; it was a question of how "religion" could be taught outside more traditional, verbal mediums. The YMCA could be both religious and non. From the interwar to the Cold War, for additional example, the Y's Christian Citizenship program was really great at rendering democratic ideals and Christian standards indistinguishable, equating religion and state. Collapsing religion with character, patriotism, and/or sports participation, the YMCA has navigated First Amendment issues and found more subtle, more broadly efficacious approaches to evangelism throughout its history.

I could go on here. But my general sense is that there's lots more of archival sleuthing to be done. The Kautz Family YMCA Archives will even give you some money for your travels. And if anyone needs any Minneapolis food or drink recommendations, I've gotten to know those along with the archives. Happy to suggest.

spacer

A Death, a Body, and the Living Word

Adam Park 


Jonathan Glover, circa 1948.
A foundational member of the Assemblies of God community died this Saturday. I knew him. From the United States to Sierra Leone, in fact, lots of people knew him. And for them that did, we knew that to be acquainted with Jonathan Glover was also to be acquainted with Someone else.

At just over 5-foot tall with shoes on, and 130-pounds soaking wet, the Someone else that Jonathan embodied was not easy to identify upon first glance. Unlikely vessel, perhaps. But then again, I hear, He was the least of these. What was clear, however, was that the Word inside Jonathan was bigger than he was. It overflowed incessantly. Everywhere. To anyone. He couldn't keep It in, nor did he try. Moments when Jonathan would become the Word were readily visible. His body would pulse with excitement. His short spine would stretch to hold him higher. He would spring up on the balls of his feet, lest Satan catch him on his heels. The volume and cadence of his voice would alter, rising and falling, quickening and pacing, punctuating and pausing. He would pronounce "God" differently, as though it was spelled with a "w" after the "G." A learned melody and sing-song style. The Word had an accent. Weberian charisma. The Word had charm. Jonathan had mastered a craft. Jonathan had been mastered by a craft. To watch Jonathan manifest the Word was like watching a bird in an updraft, effortlessly gliding, animated, held aloft, driven by an invisible thing.



Jonathan Glover's forebears. Circa 1908.
For Jonathan, to make the imperceptible perceptible was to work. Word was deed. Born in a paltry Colorado homestead in 1927, from hardy Anglo-stock came Johnny. And in the thorns and thistles, by the sweat of their brow he and his toiled for bread in a country depressed. When Jonathan felt called to minister, he chose the place that demanded the most labor of him. Crossing the Atlantic in 1962 on the steamship "African Planet," Jonathan slowly made his way to Koindu in the deepest recesses of Sierra Leone. For 23 years Jonathan ministered--hammering, chopping, digging, lifting, sawing, sweating, bleeding, and saving. Hand-mixed concrete, hand-dug wells, hand-cut logs. Jonathan MacGyver-ed his way through over a dozen hand-made buildings, structures, and wells. The Word was act, product, output. The invisible was quite visible. The Word was his calloused hands, the dirt under his fingernails.

Jonathan and Gwen, circa 1990.
As such, however, the Word was subject to the body that housed It. Retiring in the hometown national headquarters of his beloved Assemblies of God, Jonathan tinkered, toiled, and witnessed well into his twilight years. Idle hands, he never had. Idle speech, he rarely spoke. But his productive, youthful pace slowed. Jonathan's efficacy as a maker of things and a speaker of words markedly declined. Impeded by chronic neurodegenerative disease, the Word did not overflow as It once did. When Jonathan's wife of over 50 years died in 2010 it was clear that a part of Jonathan died too. In those increasingly frequent cognitive gaffes, Gwen had been Jonathan's source for names, dates, words, and verses. Helpmeets both, it was a biblically oriented symbiosis. In the cruelest of ironies--in the death of his wife and the demise of his own mind--the Word that Jonathan knew by memory left him along with his memory. Wordless.

It was strange to see Jonathan's vessel emptied. Without the Word, he was not he. Jonathan wandered aimlessly. He spat, he pinched, he hit. Nurses fed him, changed him, cleaned him. He did not know me, and I'm not sure I knew him. Minus whatever sundry neural pathways that register selfhood to selves, in the last months, I'm not sure he even knew himself. But such are bodies.

Thinking about Jonathan's life and death, the work of Candy Brown, Matt Sutton, John Modern, and Susan Harding kept coming to mind. Words. Media. The ability of things to get under the skin. The evangelical presumption that things can get under the skin. The Living Word in the world is a cornucopia of possibility and potentiality, just as much constructed as it is constructing. Jonathan took comfort in the process of the Word. As a proud representative of a thing beyond him, the horizon of Jonathan's selfhood is less bounded.

The Word is released and created in memory and oral history. The Word is a reality beckoned through cognition and speech. Forever entombed in binary code and the digitized ether of a blog. Resurrected through Google or an archival search. Summoned at a thought. Present in a recollection. Apotheosized through public prayer.

As a datum, it seems, the Word is as omnipresent as the media used to mediate it. Text, speech, radio, silicon, neuron, and Jonathan. As a datum, the Word is both strikingly mundane and eternally complex, existing outside of us because of us. Structuring structure.

But as a friend, the Word ate slow. So slow. The Word had a sweet tooth and ticklish knees. The Word once tried to put chocolate sauce, still in his pantry from 1994, on my ice cream ... in 2007. The Word watched Andy Griffith reruns every day during lunch. Perhaps you didn't know.

spacer

The R&AC Conference: Taking Religion "Seriously"

Adam Park


"Why so serious?"--The Joker

With tongue perpetually in cheek, admittedly, I get a little nervous when people get "serious." My skittish ears are therefore perked at the very mention of the s-word. In all its stern demand, the s-word happened a lot this weekend at my favorite conference ever--the Religion & American Culture Conference. And, not incidentally, the s-word happens a lot in Religious Studies. "Taking religion seriously," so it goes. As Michael Altman Twittered (sp.?) the first morning of the conference: "what does it mean 'to take X seriously'? I've heard a lot of that this morning." I second that Twitter query. Though testing my incessantly satirical nerves, I think it worthwhile to explore the nature of our cultivated tone, our asserted imperative, our assumed position, our seriousness. 

Here's what I think is going on. As Charlie McCrary suggested in his previous post, "taking religion seriously" has much to do with assertions of proximity or intimacy to our subject(s). And as Elizabeth Pritchard so insightfully argued, the scholarly injunction to take religion "seriously" is laden with secular liberal assumptions about the existence of a power-neutral space within which to discuss a given topic. Both points taken. Additionally, here's some other things I think we mean when we issue calls to take X "seriously." 


1) I'll start with a mostly benign/obvious point. Serious means both good and thorough. Since the First Biennial Conference on Religion and American Culture in 2009, Philip Goff has introduced the purpose of the conference to begin a "serious" dialogue. A serious study is a quality one. With ever the analytic, loquacious, and nimbly nuanced minds, then, serious conversation is how we academics enjoy ourselves. Serious is a scholarly word for fun. A little sad, but whatever. Conferences are our spring breaks. I got so serious Saturday that I could only eat a couple bites of granola and some Advil Sunday morning. But what happens in Indianapolis, does not stay in Indianapolis. 

2) Serious functions to maintain academic boundaries. What is not serious? To take X seriously is to contrast one's seriousness with other unlearned, popular, un-footnoted, or media soundbite discussions of X. In a room full of serious types, Besheer Mohamed had to justify his Pew-ish penchant for brevity and simplification. Cara Burnidge wondered if "history" was code for "legitimate." Probably. Serious certainly is. Language of seriousness is the rhetorical "hallmark of sound scholarship," Pritchard reminds us. Serious is not truthiness. Serious is not Trump tweets. Serious is our academic hegemon's lingua franca. Greek to others. 

3) Serious marks importance ... particularly for an embattled discipline and a presumed neglected topic. Is anyone listening? Historians? Once king in the academy, Kathryn Lofton noted, religion is now lowly pauper. Political scientists and quantitative sociologists don't take religion seriously, but we do. For it is special. To take religion seriously is to protect it. Pastoral. But one is left to wonder, we may take religious "nones" seriously, but do Pastafarians evoke our sense of seriousness? Does Kirk Cameron's acting in Left Behind? Perhaps, partial pastoral. Some things get protected by our seriousness. Other things, well, get left behind. Serious hegemony.

4) Serious is a moral posture. Seriousness is an academic ethic with a (Christian-inflected?) preoccupation with truth and pure intention. To be serious is to be a proxy to the authentic, a voice for the real. To evoke seriousness, Pritchard writes, is "rather like an instance of good manners." Though the source of all this taking religion seriously is somewhat unclear to me, I think a primary wellspring for seriousness is "lived religion." Ahlstrom didn't need serious language. Ethnographic turn. As Robert Orsi spoke at the first R&AC conference, "To take religious experiences of real presences seriously means understanding imaginary beings as having historical life and agency of their own." To believe as they is the serious mantra. Caretaker more than critic. However, as scholars of religion, Orsi adds, this "does not entail ignoring questions of social power." Somewhere between heaven and earth, to be serious is to be disoriented. To be serious requires a certain self awareness, a high degree of introspection. To be serious is to, at least partially, oppose reductionism or simplification. To take religion seriously is to enact an imperative that obliges a certain kind of relation to our religious subject and our inner selves. Charlie got it right. To be serious is to be sincere, honest, true to self and others.

Doing little more than writing a dissertation for the past three years, I've been thinking more unseriously all the while about the place of irony, satire, and humor in writing, in the academy. Levity in analysis. I think there's room. Mama Lola can take it. I would like to see more. I would like to laugh more as I learn more. I'm betting our audiences would like that too. Courtney Lacy Tweeted how "Katy Lofton's speech was a whirlwind of laughter and critique." She wondered "how will this room of traditional intellectuals respond?" Well. Encore. There is, however, a catch. Just as seriousness includes as it excludes, so too does comedy. Muhammed cartoons can kill. Just as seriousness presumes a power-neutral space for dialogue, so too does humor appeal to modern secular liberal assumptions about the right to laugh. There's an impasse here, an irony.




spacer

Saint Valentine's Pleasures

Adam Park 


The season of romance is upon us. Or, at least, a day of romance. And by some accounts, Christians romance best.

So, what's their secret? Well, it can be found in their rich material culture. Since the early 2000s, Christian marital aid and lingerie websites have been providing the adventurous faithful a wide range of romantic accessories. From nipple clamps, sex swings, and penis rings to edible underwear, prostate massagers, and beads (that you don't wear around your neck), these online marital aid ministries offer many earthly delights for holy matrimony. A most fleshly doxa, indeed.

The raison d'être for online Christian marital aid ministries, however, is not merely to aid in the enhancement of romance. Such ministries exist to provide, in the words of one website, "a safe, non-pornographic place to shop for all your Christian sex toy and romance needs, while keeping Christ at the center of your marriage." When it comes to Christian marriage, pleasure is the solution. But when it comes to shopping for pleasure-inducing goods, pornography is the problem. Packaging, product imagery, foul descriptions and vulgar toy names, and seductively-posed lingerie models have besmirched the market. The overly-sensuous agora is simply too titillating. Understanding marriage as between a husband and a wife, such ministries hold that any sexual stimuli that occurs outside of that closed relationship is misplaced and ill-gotten. To channel Douglas, pornography is erotica out of place. Christian marital aid ministries therefore whitewash. And here's how.





Technologies of censorship. Lingerie displays are particularly problematic, and require manipulation. Christian marital aid ministries diligently alter their product promotions. Image frames are manipulated and cropped, limiting the field of view. Bellybuttons, cleavage, nipples, and muscle tone are airbrushed, ridding the depicted models of their erogenous zones. And skin tone is discolored, graphically reducing human-likeness. To combat pornography, Christian marital aid ministries dismember humans.

Sex toy packaging poses its own set of problems. Some airbrush. Some depict the accessories devoid of their secular packaging. One forward-thinking website offers a service called "polybagging," where it will "apply a sticker or remove packaging" on any "inappropriate" package content. Another website hopes to produce its own product "with its own non-offensive packaging," it said, "but at this time it isn't cost affective [sic]." Religious censorship is the marketable service here. Paying for non-pornography.

Curiously, though, Christian marital aid ministries censor male bodies differently. Less, to be precise. Bellybuttons, abs, knees, necks, and even heads--so long as they belong to a male--are non-pornographic, so it goes. Perhaps male bodies are less titillating. Or, perhaps females bodies are less visually titillated. Either way, it's still a celebration of pleasure within the appropriate context.

So, if you're wondering, there are current holiday specials to satiate a variety of personal desires. And the satiation of personal/coupled desire is key, is orthodoxy. Pleasure is a gift. As Amy DeRogatis has found, so too here, sex is praise.

In Christian marital aid ministries, the holiday, the romance, the consummation, the marital bed or even the kitchen floor, is conceived as the retrieval of a feeling, an emotion, the reclamation of the body, of humanity. That which is given, so it goes, should be had. It is pleasure that guides us, marks truth, and leads us to salvation. It is the Word in the flesh.




spacer