Showing posts with label Andrea's posts. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Andrea's posts. Show all posts

Women & Gender at the Conference on Faith and History

Andrea L. Turpin

I'm getting excited for the biennial Conference on Faith and History held this year at Calvin College in Grand Rapids, MI October 4-6. My anticipation is not only linked to the hope that this Texan will get to experience some Fall. It is also linked to the large number of promising papers on the program.

This year marks the conference's 50th anniversary and I look forward to hearing reflections on where the field has been and where it is going. Even more so, I look forward to seeing first hand where it is going. One of the things that is so promising about the papers is how much the conference has diversified since I first began attending exactly ten years ago. Every single time slot of panel presentations contains at least one paper on women's or gender history and a couple contain entire competing panels. Notably, the presidential plenary by my Baylor colleague Beth Allison Barr will incorporate women's history.

Equally encouraging is the range of these papers. Recurring topics include the intellectual history of thought both by and about women, the religious lives of women of color, and the religious lives of women from multiple traditions including Muslim, Jewish, Catholic, Mormon, and Protestant. (I should add that one notable omission is that there are no papers whose main topic is religion and sexuality.)

I have bolded the papers and panels on women's and gender history below. Enjoy!

Note: The careful reader will notice that I have not listed my own panels. I will be presenting on a roundtable Friday at 4:15pm on "Christian Scholarship for Such a Time as This: A Reassessment." Women's and gender history will play a significant role in the discussion but is not the main focus. I am also indulging another of my interests by serving as commentator for a fascinating panel Saturday at 2:30pm on "Religious Education as Cultural Transmission in Twentieth-Century America."



Friday, October 5, 8:00-9:30 a.m.

Session 3: Gendered Faith in Early America: Women as Civil Authorities, Moravian Missionaries, and Disabled Christians
Meeter Center Lecture Hall

Chair: Lisa Clark Diller, Southern Adventist University
  • “Flourishing Families or Spit-in-the-Face? Women, the Book of Exodus and Civil Authority in Colonial America,” Kristina Benham, Baylor University
  • “Hearing the Gospel in a Silent World: Disability, Gender and Religion in the Massachusetts Bay Colony,” Katherine Ranum, University of Cincinnati
  • “New Madrid Earthquakes of the Cherokee Nation: Women Shaken and Bonded,” Lucinda Yang, Baylor University
Comment:   Lisa Clark Diller, Southern Adventist University

Session 7: Christian Women and the History Profession
Prince Conference Center, Hickory Room

Chair: Loretta Hunnicutt, Pepperdine University
  • Nadya Williams, University of West Georgia
  • Meghan DiLuzio, Baylor University
  • Elizabeth Marvel, Baylor University

Friday, October 5, 10:00-11:30 a.m.

Session 9: Historical Thinking and Evangelical Institutions
Prince Conference Center, Willow West

Chair:  David Swartz, Asbury University
  • “The Role of the Christian Institution in the History of Evangelical Divorce and Remarriage,” Margaret Flamingo, University of Wisconsin-Madison
  • “What Has Grand Rapids To Do With Nashville? Christian Historians Examining, Enduring, and Engaging with Popular Christian Cultures,” K. Scott Culpepper, Dordt College
  • “Does Evangelical Pietism Undermine the Life of the Mind? The Case of Bethel College, Indiana, 1947-2017,” Dennis Engbrecht, Bethel College & Timothy Erdel, Bethel College
Comment:   David Swartz, Asbury University


Friday, October 5, 2:15-3:45 p.m.

Session 17: Sacred Texts in American History
Commons Annex, Room 214 (upper level)

Chair:  John Turner, George Mason University
  • “Reconfiguring the Archive: Women and the Social Production of the Book of Mormon,” Amy Easton-Flake, Brigham Young University & Rachel Cope, Brigham Young University
  • “The Practical and Poetic Pietist: John Quincy Adams and the Bible,” Matt McCook, Oklahoma Christian University
  • “’The Bible is Assumed’: The Great Books Movement and the Place of Protestants in the ‘Great Conversation,’” Fred Beuttler, University of Chicago
  • “The Enlightenment and Modernity in Carl F.H. Henry’s Account of Western Civilization,” Mike Kulger, Northwestern College
Comment:   John Turner, George Mason University

Session 18: Political Hope in the Age of Fracture
Prince Conference Center, Willow East

Chair: Michael Hammond, Taylor University
  • “‘That Unageing Spiritual Reality’: Kathleen Raine, Temenos and the Hope of Civilization,” Eric Miller, Geneva College
  • “This Town Ain’t So Bad: Spending Heavenly Eternity in Springfield with the Simpsons,” Paul Arras, SUNY Cortland
  • “Friendship and Culture War: Wallace Stegner’s Crossing to Safety and its Historical Moment,” Matthew Stewart, Syracuse University
Comment:  Jeff Bilbro, Spring Arbor University

Session 22: Teaching Islamic History and Culture in the Christian University
Commons Annex, Alumni Board Room (upper level)

Chair: Douglas Howard, Calvin College
  • “What has Baghdad to do with Jerusalem and Athens? Situating Classical Islam within the Western Tradition,” Anthony Minnema, Samford University
  • “We Speak for Ourselves: The Use of Oral History in the Classroom to Cement the Experience of Muslim Americans in the Broader Narrative of U.S. History," Amy Poppinga, Bethel University
  • “Fostering Humility and Hospitality through the Study of Jewish and Islamic Fundamentalisms,” Sarah Miglio, Wheaton College
  • “How do you Teach Honor Killings? Sufi Transgressive Piety, Lottie Moon, and the Benefits of Comparative History,” Annalise DeVries, Samford University
Comment:  Douglas Howard, Calvin College

Session 23: Legacies of the Protestant Reformation
Meeter Center Lecture Hall

Chair: Ron Rittgers, Valparaiso University
  • “Division in Unity: Historiography and the Legacies of the Radical Reformation, ”Joe Super, Liberty University Online
  • “Margaret Baxter: ‘Nursing Mother’ of Protestant Dissenters,” Seth Osborne, Southern Baptist Theological Seminary
  • “Theological Responses to the Synod of Dort in France” (in celebration of the 500th anniversary of the synod), Martin Klauber, Trinity International University
Comment:   Ron Rittgers, Valparaiso University


Friday, October 5, 4:15-5:45 p.m.

Session 25: The Mississippi Delta and the Long Civil Rights Movement
Prince Conference Center, Willow West

Chair: John Giggie, University of Alabama
  • “Seek the Welfare of the City Where I have Sent You,” Alicia Jackson, Covenant College
  • ““She was Counsellor and Advisor”: Black Women Fraternal Leaders in the Mississippi Delta, 1940s–1970s,” Katrina Sims, Hofstra University
  • “Fannie Lou Hamer as Organic Theologian, ”Jemar Tisby, University of Mississippi
Comment:  Paul Harvey, University of Colorado

Session 26: Vocation ‘Between the Times’: Catholic Women from Revolution to Council
Commons Annex, Room 214 (upper level)

Chair: Emily McGowin, Wheaton College
  • “Vocation ‘Between the Times’: A Rule for the Active Apostolate,” Laura Eloe, University of Dayton
  • “Vocation ‘Between the Times’: Mary as a Model for Catholic Mothers in the 1950s,” Annie Huey, University of Dayton
  • “Vocation ‘Between the Times’: A Mother and a Mystic,” Joshua Wopata, University of Dayton
Comment:   Emily McGowin, Wheaton College

Session 30: Historians as Social and Moral Critics
Meeter Center Lecture Hall

Chair:  William Katerberg, Calvin College
  • “History that Heals: Reflections on Canada’s Truth and Reconciliation Commission from a Settler Historian,” William Van Arragon, King’s University
  • "The Historian as Moral Critic: John Higham, Christopher Lasch, Andrew Bacevich," John Haas, Bethel College
  • “The Artist as Historian: Carrie Mae Weems and the Photographic Archive,” Elissa Weichbrodt, Covenant College
Comment:  William Katerberg, Calvin College

Session 32: Shifting Evangelical Identities in Secularizing America
Commons Annex, Lecture Hall C/D (lower level)

Chair: Brenda Thompson Schoolfield, Bob Jones University
  • “Earthrise: The Religious Politics of a Stamp and the Role of Conspiracy in the Era of Late 1960s Fake News and Its Implications for the Social Media Age,” Bobby Griffith, The University of Oklahoma
  • ““Last at the Cross, and First at the Resurrection”: Sam Jones’s Theology of Gender,” Anderson Rouse, University of North Carolina at Greensboro
  • “Billy Graham’s Northwestern Years (1948-1952) and Emerging Evangelical and Fundamentalist Identities,” Greg Rosauer, University of Northwestern–St.Paul
Comment:  Brenda Thompson Schoolfield, Bob Jones University


Friday, October 5, 7:00 p.m.

Presidential Plenary—Beth Allison Barr, Baylor University
Prince Conference Center, Great Hall
PAUL, MEDIEVAL WOMEN AND 50 YEARS OF THE CFH: NEW PERSPECTIVES


Saturday, October 6, 8:00-9:30 a.m.

Session 33: Defending Black Citizenship: African-American and White Christians on Abolition, Prohibition, and Lynching in the U.S. South and Borderlands
DeVos Communication Center, Bytwerk Theater (lower level)

Chair: Paul Harvey, University of Colorado
  • “Black Pastors Defending Black Bodies: Lynching and the Church,” Malcolm Foley, Baylor University   
  • “Religious Abolitionism and the Quest for African-American Citizenship in Cincinnati,” Scott Anderson, University of Mary-Hardin Baylor
  • “Defending Black Manhood: African Americans’ Religious (Anti-)Prohibition Activism,” Brendan Payne, North Greenville University
Comment:   Pearl Young, University of North Carolina

Session 40: Ideals of Womanhood in American Christianity
Meeter Center Lecture Hall

Chair: Margaret Bendroth, Congregational Library & Archives
  • ““Let any anxious and pious mother remember the perils, and the rescue of the son of Monica”: St. Monica as Female Exemplar in Nineteenth-Century Protestantism,” Paul Gutacker, Baylor University
  • ““I’m for the ERA”: Faith, Feminism, and the Active Politics of a Southern Baptist First Lady,” Elizabeth Flowers, Texas Christian University
  • “The ‘Noblest Career of All’: Housekeeping, Homemaking, and the Ideal of Evangelical Postwar Domesticity,” Adina Johnson Kelley, Baylor University
Comment:  Margaret Bendroth


Saturday, October 6, 10:00-11:30 a.m.

Session 42: Women, Race, and Authority in American Religious Movements
Meeter Center Lecture Hall

Chair: Jeanne Petit, Hope College
  • “Unexpected Scope for Work: Black Women Doctors and the Seventh-day Adventist Church,” Lisa Clark Diller, Southern Adventist University
  • “Women’s Protests at the American Presbyterian Congo Mission, 1916-1933,” Kimberly Hill, University of Texas at Dallas
  •  “Shaping Women of ‘Unsubdued Spirit’: Rebecca Gratz and Female Religious Leadership in Antebellum American Judaism,” Elise Leal, Whitworth University
Comment:  Jeanne Petit, Hope College

Session 47: Versions of Holiness: Saints and Nuns from Medieval England to Africa and the American West
Commons Annex, Room 214 (upper level)

Chair: Jennifer Hevelone-Harper, Gordon University
  • ““Present your bodies a sacrifice to the Lord”: The Physical and Spiritual Care of Nuns in Late Medieval England,” Elizabeth Marvel, Baylor University
  • “Constructing Houses in the American West: Candlelight, Bricks, and Communion,” Danae Jacobson, University of Notre Dame
  • “Women on the Move from a Global Perspective: A Gendered Analysis of Saints’ Lives in Medieval Ethiopia and Europe,” Anna Redhair, Baylor University
Comment:  Jennifer Hevelone-Harper, Gordon University

Session 48: Evangelical Uses of the Past
Prince Conference Center, Willow East

Chair: Jay Green, Covenant College
  • ““Everyone is a child of destiny”: Henrietta Mears and the Meaning of History,” Amber Thomas, University of Edinburgh
  • “Our City: History Creation and late Nineteenth-Century Urban Evangelicalism,” Andrew MacDonald, Trinity Evangelical Divinity School
  • “Conservative Resurgence or Conservative Takeover? Usable History at The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary,” Lisa Weaver Swartz, Asbury Theological Seminary
Comment:  Jay Green, Covenant College


Saturday, October 6, 2:30-4:00 p.m.

Session 52: Beyond the Voting Booth: Evangelicals and Race, Gender, and Memory
Meeter Center Lecture Hall

Chair:  Bill Svelmoe, St. Mary’s College
  • “Exhibiting Evangelicalism: Protestant Public Memory at the Billy Graham Center Museum,” Devin Manzullo-Thomas, Messiah College
  • “White Evangelicals as ‘a people’: The Church Growth Movement from India to the United States,” Jesse Curtis, Temple University
  • “Grooming Evangelical Womanhood: The Pioneer Girls and Gendered Identity,” Rebecca Koerselman, Northwestern University
Comment:  Bill Svelmoe, St. Mary’s College

Session 56: ‘For whatsoever things were written aforetime were written for our learning”: Christian Uses of the Past to Shape the Present and Future
Prince Conference Center, Willow East

Chair: Seth Perry, Princeton University
  • “Lost Cause Hagiography: Rewriting Saints Felicity and Perpetua as Southern Catholic Martyrs,” David Roach, Baylor University
  • “‘Crying out against Conditions’: Protestants and Labor, 1908-1940,” Tori Jessen, University of Alabama
  • “‘Beloved prostitutes and rough fishermen’: Appeals to the Early Church in the Emerging Church Movement,” John Young, University of Alabama
Comment:  Seth Perry, Princeton University

spacer

Book List on Women, Gender, and Sex in American Religious History

Andrea L. Turpin
  
This fall I get to teach one of my favorite classes: my graduate course on Women, Gender, and Sex in American Religious History. One of the readings I assign for the first day is quite possibly my favorite historiographic essay of all time, Catherine Brekus's “Introduction: Searching for Women in Narratives of American Religious History,” in The Religious History of American Women: Reimagining the Past, ed. Brekus (North Carolina, 2007).

In this ten-year-old essay, Brekus examines why so many synthetic works of American religious history ignore women and why so many synthetic works of American women's history ignore religion. She makes a compelling case that the answer is not that scholarship on American women's religious history doesn't exist--and that both omissions leave our understanding of our collective past significantly impoverished.

Yet five years after the release of The Religious History of American Women, the December 2012 issue of the Journal of American History dedicated to a state-of-the-field analysis of American women's and gender history hardly mentioned religion at all. And as late as 2016 I was still seeing so many book lists for lay readers interested in American religious history that didn't include books by or about women that I was moved to write my first ever blog post on the subject.

But I am encouraged by my class, both the students in it and the books available to assign for it. The course has enrolled a large number of students, and roughly equal numbers of women and men are interested in the topic. (I wrote a guest post last year over at the Anxious Bench reflecting on my experience teaching an earlier version of this course to 6 men and 1 woman!) And even though I last taught the course only a year and half ago, I changed about one-third of the books on the syllabus because so much excellent work has been published in the last two years.

Each week the class reads one book and an additional article or book chapter on a complementary topic. In the readings for the course, I strive for diversity of multiple types: religious traditions, race and ethnicity, historical time period, styles of writing, and classic vs. recent works. In different years the course ends up having slightly different emphases depending on the interests of the students enrolled, my research at the time, what books have recently been published, and the directions in which the field is developing. 

Particularly noteworthy in this iteration is the recent expansion of scholarship on religion and sexuality. And it is a sign of the vitality of the field of women, gender, and sex in American religious history that there are so many excellent books that I could have included that did not make this particular semester's list. Judging from the books on this year's syllabus, shout out to the university presses of Oxford, North Carolina, and Cornell, who have all published multiple titles in this area.

Now without further ado, for your reading pleasure, here are the books for this year: 
 
Joan Wallach Scott, Sex and Secularism (Princeton, 2017) 

Carol F. Karlsen, The Devil in the Shape of a Woman: Witchcraft in Colonial New England (W.W. Norton, 1987)

Susan Juster, Disorderly Women: Sexual Politics & Evangelicalism in Revolutionary New England (Cornell, 1994)

Laurel Thatcher Ulrich, A House Full of Females: Plural Marriage and Women's Rights in Early Mormonism, 1835-1870 (Knopf, 2017)

Kathi Kern, Mrs. Stanton’s Bible (Cornell, 2001)

Andrea L. Turpin, A New Moral Vision: Gender, Religion, and the Changing Purposes of American Higher Education, 1837–1917 (Cornell, 2016)

*I offer the book to my students at my author's discount so I don't make a profit. We use this day to discuss not only the topic, but also the process of writing a dissertation and turning it into a book.

Sarah Imhoff, Masculinity and the Making of American Judaism (Indiana, 2017)

Kristin Kobes DuMez, A New Gospel for Women: Katharine Bushnell and the Challenge of Christian Feminism (Oxford, 2015)

Marie Griffith, Moral Combat: How Sex Divided American Christians and Fractured American Politics (Basic, 2017)

Heather R. White, Reforming Sodom: Protestants and the Rise of Gay Rights (North Carolina, 2015)

Daniel Williams, Defenders of the Unborn: The Pro-Life Movement before Roe v. Wade (Oxford, 2016)

Ula Yvette Taylor, The Promise of Patriarchy: Women and the Nation of Islam (North Carolina, 2017)

James M. Ault, Spirit and Flesh: Life in a Fundamentalist Baptist Church (Knopf, 2004)

As I mentioned earlier, in addition to these books, the class reads several standalone articles and book chapters. I want to highlight three 2018 edited volumes that make helpful contributions to the field and are the source of some of these chapters:

Eds. Gillian Frank, Bethany Moreton, & Heather R. White, Devotions and Desires: Histories of Sexuality and Religion in the United States (North Carolina, 2018)

Eds. Michele Lise Tarter & Catie Gill, New Critical Studies on Early Quaker Women, 1650-1800 (Oxford, 2018)

Eds. Leilah Danielson, Marian Mollin, & Doug Rossinow, The Religious Left in Modern America: Doorkeepers of a Radical Faith (Palgrave Macmillan, 2018)

I suspect next time I teach this course, several readers of this blog will have produced excellent new work in the field to include!

spacer

Paige Patterson, Beth Moore, and the History of Evangelical Women's Education

Andrea L. Turpin

Today over at The Conversation I was asked to share my reflections on what the history of evangelical women's education can tell us about Paige Patterson, Beth Moore, and the possible future of the Southern Baptist Convention.

Here is a taste:

Southern Baptist Convention leader Paige Patterson was asked to step down early Wednesday morning following a meeting of the board of trustees of Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary, where he served as president. With a following of over 15 million, Southern Baptists are America's largest Protestant denomination. 

Trustees were responding to a petition by over 3,000 Southern Baptist women regarding what they called Patterson’s “unbiblical” remarks on womanhood, sexuality and domestic violence. In an audio recording from 2000 that surfaced recently, Patterson was heard counseling a woman to stay with her abusive husband. In another sermon, he commented on a 16-year-old girl's body. And even as the trustees met, news broke that Patterson allegedly advised a female seminary student not to report a rape to the police.

It would be easy to assume evangelical Christian educators like Patterson uniformly discriminate against women because they believe the Bible teaches women to submit to men. But, as a historian of women, religion, and higher education, I know that the story is not that simple: Evangelicals actually led in opening higher education to women.

Finish reading here.
spacer

Interview with Adam Laats on Fundamentalist U

Andrea L. Turpin

As you might imagine given my scholarly interests, I love to see good work come out on the history of religion in American higher education. That's why I was delighted to interview Adam Laats on his new book Fundamentalist U: Keeping the Faith in American Higher Education (New York: Oxford University Press, 2018). Adam is a scholar I highly admire not only for the depth of his research but also for his commitment to rigorous fairness to historical characters from across the ideological spectrum. So without further ado, here is Adam weighing in on everything from the nature of evangelicalism to why religious historians should care about the history of education to what to do about the culture wars:

AT: What led you to write Fundamentalist U?

AL: The most interesting questions for me are pretty basic: What are schools for? What counts as “good” when it comes to education? From that perspective, there is nothing more fascinating than the network of evangelical colleges, universities, institutes, and seminaries. In the twentieth century, they represented the most significant dissenting type of school in the United States.

AT: Why is studying the history of education important for historians of religion?

AL: When it comes to religion (and politics, too, but that’s another story), education is where the rubber hits the road. There is no better way to understand a religious group as it truly is than to examine the ways it tries to pass itself on to every new generation. Beyond creeds and catechisms, curriculum represents the unvarnished truth of what a religious group considers absolutely vital for children to know.

AT: Your book is entitled Fundamentalist U, but you cover colleges and universities you label “fundamentalist” and those you label “evangelical.” How would you define the difference?

AL: By the middle of the twentieth century, a group of fundamentalist Protestants hoped to reform their movement, to introduce what Carl Henry called in 1947 “progressive Fundamentalism with a social message.” To my mind, the neo-evangelical reform, which eventually became known simply as “evangelical,” is still best described in Henry’s terms; the theology of fundamentalism is still there, but some of the non-theological conservative cultural ideas are scraped away, the inward-looking exclusivity is abandoned in favor of engagement with the outside world.

When I began this research, I was expecting to find a hard, clean institutional break between “evangelical” and “fundamentalist” institutions in the middle of the twentieth century, the kind George Marsden described at Fuller Seminary. In fact, even at schools most firmly associated with either the “fundamentalist” side of the evangelical family or the “evangelical” side, I found lingering connections and associations to the other side. As with all family feuds, the division between “fundamentalists” and “evangelicals” was never as clear as some historians and partisans would like it to be. Fundamentalists never gave up on claiming higher academic and scientific standards, though they often despaired of ever achieving the mainstream recognition of their academic superiority they thought they deserved. Evangelicals never abdicated their fundamentalist religious purity, though they abandoned their insistence that only fundamentalists could be trusted intellectually or morally.

AT: What did you find to be the relationship between theological and political conservatism at these institutions?

AL: This is something evangelical intellectuals don’t like to hear, but I’ll say it: Many times, political conservatism—or, more precisely, a vague but powerful cultural traditionalism that included political conservatism—became a more influential popular measure of “true” fundamentalism than did theological conservatism. Colleges and universities were subjected to endless, ruthless scrutiny by the broad evangelical public. This scrutiny sometimes included theological notions, but more commonly dealt with issues such as student behavior, faculty affiliations, and political or social conventions. Any whisper that a school had slipped from full-throated dedication to key traditional ideas or norms could cause panic in that school’s administrators, alumni, and trustees.

My favorite example of this ever-present tension came in 1936 when President J. Oliver Buswell of Wheaton College confronted J. Gresham Machen about his new Westminster Seminary. Professor Machen had recently left Princeton Seminary to open his new school, and Buswell was concerned about rumors Buswell had heard. Was it true, Buswell demanded, that Westminster students were allowed to drink alcohol? Machen confirmed it. There was no theological reason to prohibit alcohol, Machen insisted. In his considered opinion, teetotalism was not a Christian imperative, but a bland bit of Main Street prudism. 

AT: You observe that fundamentalist and evangelical colleges challenged some of the epistemological assumptions of mainstream higher education, but very closely mirrored the institutional forms of mainstream higher education. How, in turn, would you say that fundamentalist and evangelical colleges and universities have affected more mainstream American higher education?

AL: Most significantly, I’d say, conservative-evangelical colleges and universities (both those that called themselves “evangelical” and those that called themselves “fundamentalist”) influenced mainstream American higher education by offering an intellectual and institutional haven for an alternative epistemology, one that didn’t immediately dismiss the influence of the supernatural.  How did that impact mainstream higher education? In at least two significant ways. First, students from evangelical colleges often also attended mainstream schools, either as transfer students or graduate students. The training those students received in their conservative-evangelical colleges—intellectual training, but perhaps more importantly a sense of themselves as dissenting scholars—must have had an enormous influence on their work in mainstream institutions.

Second, scholarship supported by evangelical institutions has had its own direct impact on mainstream thinking and institutions. We see the results in several fields. Though many secular scientists dismiss it, the work of evangelical scientists has made significant inroads in both the popular mind and in mainstream institutions such as the National Institutes of Health. In the field of academic history, too, the best work on the history of evangelicalism has been nurtured by the network of evangelical institutions themselves. When I studied twentieth-century religious history as a graduate student at the very unreligious University of Wisconsin, for example, we began and ended with the work of historians such as George Marsden, Mark Noll, Edith Blumhofer, Joel Carpenter, and many other scholars nurtured by evangelical institutions of higher education.

AT: Would you say the record of twentieth-century fundamentalist and evangelical institutions on race, class, and gender inclusivity is better or worse than the record of mainstream higher education? Why?

AL: In the most obvious senses, in my opinion, the record of most evangelical institutions of higher ed has been much worse when it comes to questions of racial and gender inclusivity. Most obviously, a few fundamentalist colleges such as Bob Jones University clung desperately to racial segregation and insisted on traditional gender hierarchies. If we only get to tell one story from the history of evangelical higher education, that is it. But if we can take time to dig beyond the obvious, we see a more complicated story. At many evangelical schools, for instance, activists from a variety of racial backgrounds used the long history of evangelical anti-racism to help move their institutions in a more positive direction racially. After all, American evangelicals had a long tradition of anti-racist activism and many institutional activists were able to draw on that history to call for reforms. When it comes to questions of sexual identity and gender identity, though, twentieth-century evangelical schools—ALL of them—have a much worse record of inclusion, from my perspective (though that was not true in the nineteenth century).

The question gets more complicated when it comes to issues of class. For theological reasons, many evangelical institutions actively reached out to non-elite populations, often explicitly and repeatedly rejecting elitist academic standards in favor of spreading the Gospel message as widely as possible. But across the course of the twentieth century (at four-year liberal arts colleges more than schools from the Bible-institute tradition, though all evangelical colleges participated in this trend to some extent) evangelical institutions moved toward mainstream ideas about academic elitism. Part of that process was due to nuts-and-bolts questions of accreditation. Part was due to a more nebulous pursuit of academic prestige. For whatever reasons, many evangelical institutions in the twentieth century became less focused on reaching all people and mimicked the elite academic standards of mainstream and mainline colleges.

AT: You note, “[O]ur culture wars are not between educated people on one side and uneducated people on the other….Rather, our culture wars are usually fiercest between two groups of people who have been educated in very different ways.” Given this, what would you see as the way forward toward creating a more cooperative and productive American political culture?

AL: The challenge, as I see it, is to abdicate positions of privilege when none of us is willing to even admit we occupy those positions, and when we certainly don’t trust our culture-war foes to do the same. From the conservative side, many of the white conservative evangelicals in the institutions I studied wouldn’t like to admit it, but they really do yearn for an imagined past and a fantasy future in which America was somehow truly Christian and can somehow be “made great again.” There is a palpable sense among white conservative evangelicals of being kicked out unfairly of positions of power and privilege. On the other side, secular progressives like me can suffer from a similarly unacknowledged sense of privilege in academic and intellectual life. Secular academics often delegitimize and demonize any sort of thinking that does not proceed from secular, materialist grounds.

No one will like this prescription, but I think conservative evangelicals—of every racial background—need to get over their implicit assumption that they should be able to dictate social policy to match their religious beliefs. At the same time, progressive secular folks need to wrestle more profoundly and more humbly with the fact that people of good will have honest and important differences when it comes to basic assumptions about the ways we know things and the ways we define good and evil.

AT: What do you see as the most significant contribution of your research to our historical understanding of fundamentalism and evangelicalism? AKA, if we could make one change to how we teach these topics based on reading Fundamentalist U, what would you want it to be?

AL: We need to stop teaching that American evangelicalism can ever be properly defined by theological lists. Yes, Bebbington’s four distinctives (conversionism, biblicism, crucicentrism, and activism) can help people understand the gist of evangelical theology, but they can never define American evangelicalism as it really is. It is impossible to understand American evangelicalism in the twentieth century without grasping the feeling of usurped proprietary interest in America shared by many white evangelicals, just as it would be impossible to understand American Catholicism without understanding its immigrant history. Looking at evangelical educational institutions forces us to acknowledge the obvious fact that theology is only one part of the evangelical experience.

AT: Thanks, Adam!



spacer

Undergraduates Actually Want a Liberal Arts Education

Andrea L. Turpin

Undergraduate students actually want a liberal arts education—when presented with the arguments for it. How do I know?

First, some background: this year the College of Arts & Sciences at Baylor University approved a unified core curriculum for all of its students, from physics majors to English majors. Like all human products, this specific core has its strengths and weaknesses. But I love working for an institution that values the liberal arts enough to require a large proportion of its students to take courses across a fairly broad range of subjects. In fact, several of the courses in the core are straight-up required—all students must take exactly those courses. The rest of the core consists of the more common “distribution list” system whereby students select courses from among several options in each area. After fulfilling the core requirements, A&S students complete their degree with a combination of electives and additional requirements for their particular major.

In the town hall faculty meetings leading up to finalizing the content of the core, I shared an exercise I have done with students four times now, stretching over nearly a decade. This exercise has yielded uniform and, to me, surprising results: undergraduate students really want a large liberal arts core curriculum. Let me explain.

Given my research interests, I like to work the history of higher education into my courses. It always proves popular because students rarely get it in their other classes and they find it so obviously relevant to their lives. I have managed to work this particular exercise into a course I taught once at Notre Dame on American reform movements and a course I have taught three times at Baylor on the Gilded Age and Progressive Era. Because of enrollment policies at both institutions, these classes all included a large number of students who were not history majors.

James McCosh
During a week spent teaching the massive changes to American higher education that occurred in the decades around 1900, I hold an in-class debate on whether a college curriculum should consist primarily of required courses or primarily of electives. Before class, I have students read the respective arguments advanced by James McCosh, president of Princeton (1868-1888), and Charles William Eliot, president of Harvard (1869-1909).


In brief, McCosh defended a more traditional, largely required liberal arts curriculum by arguing that not all courses impart the same level of mental training and, human nature being what it is, most students would elect the easiest courses if given the opportunity. McCosh added that many students only discover their talent for and interest in a subject during a course they would never have elected to take. Finally, he asserted that full human development requires fostering several different types of mental capacities, and true education requires a certain breadth of knowledge about the world. Meanwhile, Eliot defended a “new departure” in college education by boldly arguing for an entirely elective curriculum. He argued that students enter college with exposure from high school to a wide variety of subjects and already know their tastes and talents. They would dedicate themselves more to classes that genuinely interest them, and would thereby better learn the sorts of reasoning skills that can be actually be gained through any number of widely varying courses. Simultaneously, they would thus better directly prepare themselves for work after graduation.
Charles William Eliot

For RiAH’s readership, I should note a similar argument between these educators over collegiate religion. As I discuss in more detail in my book (along with their views on women's education!), McCosh defended requiring students to attend chapel—although you cannot make a horse drink, you have a moral obligation to lead him to water—whereas Eliot made chapel voluntary and sought to induce students to attend by filling the pulpit with a rotating supply of famous ministers.

In class, I assign students to teams and have them draw on McCosh’s and Eliot’s respective arguments to debate the nature of an ideal college curriculum. I then force students into an all-or-nothing choice—entirely required courses vs. entirely elective courses—and have them vote what they really think (as opposed to speaking for the side to which I had assigned them for the debate).

I have been asking students this question since Fall 2009 (with the most recent poll being Fall 2017) and the result always is the same. Every. Single. Time. Here it is:

50% vote for entirely required, and 50% vote for entirely elective. Let this sink in for a minute. Fully half of my students believe so strongly in the value of a robust liberal arts education that they are willing to give up all choice in the curriculum to get it. And the half that voted for an entirely elective curriculum does not actually find that forced choice ideal—they would prefer that some of the curriculum be required. After the initial vote, I let students choose between “greater than 50% required” vs. “around 15% required,” and it still comes out 50-50, although some students switch camps. It’s important to note we were debating requiring specific classes, not merely requiring selecting from distribution lists. So students were voting for greater than 50% of their curriculum being exactly defined.

Moral of the story: When they have a chance to think through the best arguments from educators of the past, students buy into the idea of a liberal arts core more than we think they do...even to the point where half of them don’t think 15% is enough and are willing to go with greater than 50% to get more. And even to the point where half of the them would recommend an entirely required college curriculum over one where nothing was required.

Although I am considerably more in favor of majors and electives than was McCosh, I believe that overall students benefit from a comparatively larger liberal arts core, for the reasons he advanced. It should be an encouragement to those of us who teach in what may be the ultimate humanities discipline—history—that when students hear those arguments, so many of them agree. We just need to share that history with them. Fortunately, that’s what we do well.
spacer

U.S. Women, Gender, & Sexuality Papers at the American Society of Church History

Andrea L. Turpin

I hope to see many readers at the annual conference of the American Society of Church History (ASCH) next week! This year the ASCH meets concurrently with the American Historical Association (AHA) in Washington, DC from Thursday, January 4 through Sunday, January 7. (Which is, as always, the day before our classes start at Baylor...) Specifically, ASCH panels meet at the Dupont Circle Hotel.




I am pleased to report that most time slots feature at least one paper on women, gender, and/or sexuality in U.S. religious history. Indeed, on Friday morning there are two entire panels on the subject that—unfortunately—conflict with each other. Nearly all the papers in this field this year focus on Protestants, but there are a large number that consider women and gender in American religion within an international context. Recurring themes include feminism and anti-feminism, the intersection of gender and race—and to a lesser extent class—women's religious thought (which makes my intellectual history heart happy), and, of course, women's roles within Christian communities. There are a few papers on masculinity and sexuality, and I would love to see even more in future years.

So, without further ado, I've listed below in bold the papers and panels explicitly featuring U.S. women, gender, and/or sexuality. Enjoy!

Friday, January 5, 8:30 AM – 10:00 AM
American Evangelical “Niche” Ministries and Religious Negotiation of the Postwar Era
Foxhall Ballroom (Ground Floor)

Chair: Darren Dochuk, University of Notre Dame
Papers: “‘Free on the Inside’: Evangelical Prison Ministry in the Age of Law and Order”
Aaron Griffith, Duke University Divinity School
“Piety, Pageants and Playing Indian: Gendered Identity at Summer Camps in the Postwar Era”
Rebecca A. Koerselman, Northwestern College

“‘There is talk of Black Power…it is time somebody talked about God Power’: Evangelical Sports Ministries and the Black Athlete in
the Long 1960s”
Paul Emory Putz, Baylor University
Comment: Neil J. Young, George Mason University

Friday, January 5, 10:30 AM – 12:00 PM
U.S. Protestant Women and Transatlantic Intellectual Cultures in
the Nineteenth Century
Dupont Ballroom B (Ground Floor)

Chair: Candy Gunther Brown, Indiana University
Papers: “Pious Mothers of the Early Church”: Antebellum Women
Historians and the Christian Past”
Paul Gutacker, Baylor University
“Southern Belle, Southern Metaphysician: German Thought and Augusta Jane Evans’s Gendered Apologetics”
Joel Iliff, Baylor University
“Seeing Farther: Mary Virginia Terhune Interprets Darwin for Her
Readers”
Sara S. Frear, Houston Baptist University
Comment: Margaret Bendroth, Congregational Library & Archives


Friday, January 5, 10:30 AM – 12:00 PM
Roundtable: White Protestant Women and the Feminist Movement: Critically Assessing Kristin Kobes Du Mez’s Katharine Bushnell
Georgetown Room (Second Floor)

Chair: Heath W. Carter, Valparaiso University
Papers: “‘The White Life for Two’: The Racial Origins of Sexual Purity”
Sara Moslener, Central Michigan University
“What is Feminism Outside a Mass Movement? ‘Evangelical Feminism’ and the Class-Conscious Feminist Movement It Rejected”
Janine Giordano Drake, University of Great Falls
“Katharine Bushnell, Pandita Ramabai, and the ‘World-Wide Sisterhood of Women’”
Anneke Stasson, Indiana Wesleyan University
“Contentious Women? The Response of Protestant Women’s Organizations to the Fundamentalist-Modernist Controversy”
Andrea L. Turpin, Baylor University
Comment: Kristin Kobes Du Mez, Calvin College


Friday, January 5, 1:30 PM – 3:00 PM
Feminism or Public Housekeeping? Liberal Protestant Women’s Work in the 20th Century
Dupont Ballroom A (Ground Floor)

Chair and Comment: Peter J. Thuesen, Indiana University-Purdue
University Indianapolis
Papers: “The Secularization of Women’s Role in Mid-Twentieth-Century Mainline Protestantism”
Margaret Bendroth, Congregational Library & Archives
“The Maternalist Theology of Margaret Mead”
Elesha J. Coffman, Baylor University
“Diaconal Maternalism”
Jenny Wiley Legath, Center for the Study of Religion


Friday, January 5, 3:30 PM – 5:00 PM
A Century of Activism in the Methodist Theological Tradition
Georgetown Room (Second Floor)

Chair and Comment: Morris Davis, Drew University
Papers: “The Worth of the Slave: Arguments for the Freedom of the Slave in Early Wesleyan Methodist Connection Poetry and Hymns”
Patrick Eby, Wesley Seminary, Indiana Wesleyan University
“Southern Methodist Women and the Social Gospel: Race Relations and Industrial Labor Activism in the Early Twentieth Century”
Chelsea Hodge, University of Arkansas
“The Methodist Episcopal Church and Birth Control”
Ashley B. Dreff, Hood Theological Seminary


Saturday, January 6, 10:30 AM – 12:00 PM
Making White Evangelicals: Racial Encounters and Religious
Identities in the Second Half of the Twentieth Century
Glover Park Ballroom (Ground Floor)

Chair and Comment: Randall Stephens, Northumbria University
Papers: “The Southernization of Evangelicalism: Religious Broadcasting and Massive Resistance in the 1960s”
Paul Matzko, Pennsylvania State University
“A Colorblind Campus? White Evangelical Colleges and Black Students in the Era of Civil Rights”
Jesse Curtis, Temple University
“‘That’s real manhood’: Promise Keepers, Racial Reconciliation, and Muscular Christianity”
Hunter Hampton, University of Missouri


Saturday, January 6, 1:30 PM – 3:00 PM
Foreign Missions, Domestic Consequences: A Roundtable
Glover Park Ballroom (Ground Floor)

Chair: Christine Heyrman, University of Delaware
Papers: “Missionaries Write the World: Reception of Foreign
Missionary Texts in 19th Century America”
Emily Conroy-Krutz, Michigan State University
“Ritualizing Human Rights: Protestant Churchwomen and the United Nations in the Postwar Era”
Gale L. Kenny, Barnard College

“World Disorder and American Protestant Political Mobilization in the 1940s”
Gene Zubovich, Washington University in St. Louis
“Heathen Resonances”
Kathryn Gin Lum, Stanford University

Saturday, January 6, 1:30 PM – 3:00 PM
The Body Social and Socialized Bodies in Puritan New England
Dupont Ballroom (Ground Floor)

Chair: Douglas Winiarski, University of Richmond
Papers: “The Haughty Daughters of Zion: Fashioning Early New
England”
Martha L. Finch, Missouri State University

“States in Motion: Social Justice, Distributive Justice, in Early New England”
Scott McDermott, Albany State University
“The freedom of this Body Politick”: Puritanism and the Problem of Godly Rule
Adrian Chastain Weimer, Providence College
Comment: James P. Byrd, Vanderbilt Divinity School


Saturday, January 6, 3:30 PM – 5:00 PM

Christian America and the Promise of Good Government
Foxhall Ballroom (Ground Floor)

Chair: Jennifer Graber, University of Texas, Austin
Papers: “I am FOR the ERA”: Faith, Feminism, and the Activist Politics of a Southern Baptist First Lady”
Elizabeth Flowers, Texas Christian University

“Nelle Morton, Southern Christian Activism, and Making the Best of Bad Government”
Alison Greene, Mississippi State University

“‘They thought the world had ended, and they thought it was their doom’: How Midwestern Christians Made Sense of the Crises of the
1930s and Came to Terms with Federal Aid.”
Randall Stephens, Northumbria University
“‘We the People of the Brawley Migratory Farm Labor Camp,’
Re-Constituting American Religions on the Margins of the Nation”
Jonathan Ebel, University of Illinois
Comment: Heather Curtis, Tufts University

Sunday, January 7, 11:00 AM – 12:30 PM
Mormonism and its Institutions
Georgetown Room (Second Floor)

Chair: Sonia Hazard, Franklin & Marshall College
Papers: “A Compromise to Save the University of Utah”
Brian Ricks, Independent Scholar
“Three Decades of Change in the Institutional Support of Mormon
Women’s History”
J. B. Haws, Brigham Young University

Comment: Audience

Sunday, January 7, 11:00 AM – 12:30 PM
Norms and Movements after World War II
Dupont Ballroom (Ground Floor)

Chair: Elizabeth Flowers, Texas Christian University
Papers: “‘For such a time as this’: The Esther Motif, Providence, and Evangelical Political Engagement after World War II”
Amber Thomas, University of Edinburgh

“‘Keeping the Lines of Communication Open’: The Malone Consultations and the Limits of Neighborliness in American Protestantism
in the Mid-Twentieth Century”
Devin C. Manzullo-Thomas, Messiah College
“The Catholic Church and the Discourse of Development, 1945-1967”
Joshua David Bishop, Fordham University
“‘Most Outstanding Pastor’s Wife’: Competition, Southern Baptists,
and Ideals of Femininity in the 1950s”
Adina Johnson, Baylor University

Comment: Audience

ADDENDUM: Here are some affiliate sessions on the topic that look excellent (and expand the field beyond Protestantism):

American Catholic Historical Association 12: American Catholic Sexual Revolution
Saturday, January 6, 2018: 8:30 AM-10:00 AM
Executive Room (Omni Shoreham, West Lobby)

Chair: Monica Mercado, Colgate University
Papers: "The Cultural Margin of Faith: Ingrid Bergman, Anna Magnani, and Alternative Portraits of Catholic Women in Postwar Film"
Anthony Smith, University of Dayton
"Sex, Catholic Style: The Sexual Revolution, Women’s Liberation, and Marriage Magazine, 1960–75"
Mary Henold, Roanoke College
"The Spiritual Side of the Gay Rights Struggle: The Case of Dignity/New York"
Thomas F. Rzeznik, Seton Hall University
Comment: Monica Mercado, Colgate University


Conference on Faith and History 2: Roundtable Discussion: Writing Women’s Religious Biography
Saturday, January 6, 2018: 10:30 AM-12:00 PM
Lincoln West (Washington Hilton, Concourse Level)

Chair: Heather Hartung Vacek, Pittsburgh Theological Seminary
Comment: Kristin Kobes Du Mez, Calvin College , David Holland, Harvard Divinity School , Nancy Koester, independent scholar and Matthew Avery Sutton, Washington State University





spacer

Democracy, Higher Education, and the Problem of the Common Good

Andrea L. Turpin

A month ago I attended two national conferences on back-to-back weekends: the Society for U.S. Intellectual History (USIH) met October 26-29 in Dallas, TX and the History of Education Society (HES) met November 2-5 in Little Rock, AR. A week and a half of intensive immersion in the current scholarship of two overlapping fields made some common themes jump out. (And also produced fascinating insights into the variable quality of Marriott hotels. But I digress.)

Specifically, I was struck by historians' interest in two topics: the concept of the common good and the problem of how values are, or are not, transmitted to the next generation. I suspect these themes jumped out at me in part because they seem so salient in the current widespread breakdown of civil dialogue. Both of these lenses prove helpful for producing a clearer understanding of U.S. history, especially U.S. religious history—and for seeing how best to frame that history for our students today.

The question of the common good was raised most forcefully in a pair of book panels, one from each conference. USIH dedicated a plenary session to James Kloppenberg’s monumental work Toward Democracy: The Struggle for Self-Rule in European and American Thought (Oxford, 2016). A fair amount of the panelist and audience questions revolved around the role of religious beliefs, past and present, in forming and sustaining democracy. In answer to one of these questions, Kloppenberg articulated his conviction that some conception of the common good is necessary to ground democracy; otherwise politics becomes a zero-sum game. He asserted that historically democracy in the North Atlantic world grew in large part from Jewish and Christian roots—but that most religious and moral systems advocate some version of the golden rule that provides democracy’s necessary ethic of reciprocity. Therefore, democracy can certainly thrive in a climate of religious pluralism, but he fears it might not survive a devolution of belief in our responsibility as individual citizens to advance the common good. (Though Kloppenberg noted that he is by temperament a cautious optimist about our nation’s ability to rally around this ideal more robustly in the future.)


The question thus arises how past generations of Americans have successfully produced a commitment to the common good—and how we can do so again today. A partial answer comes from the book panel hosted by HES the next week on Charles Dorn’s For the Common Good: A New History of Higher Education in America (Cornell, 2017). Dorn’s book examines the different purposes higher education has served throughout American history—but notes that inculcating civic-mindedness has been present throughout. Instilling in students concern for the public welfare has, however, often been eclipsed by competing purposes. Those he details are the ideals of practicality, commercialism, and affluence. In other words, higher education has frequently been largely valued as an avenue to some sort of worldly success—which makes sense, considering how expensive it can be in terms of both money and time. Nevertheless, the existence of a through line of commitment to the common good among higher educational institutions throughout American history provides a rich heritage for contemporary colleges and universities to draw on.

Dorn also served as one of the commentators for the HES panel on my book, A New Moral Vision: Gender, Religion, and the Changing Purposes of American Higher Education, 1837-1917 (Cornell, 2016). He rightly noted that I too perceive the question of the nature of the public welfare to have loomed large in the educational debates that underlay our current college and university landscape. He put the question to me of whether the common good was solely in the eye of the beholder during the fractious discussions about the respective roles of gender, religion, and class in higher education that I analyze—or whether there was some criteria that educational founders, leaders, administrators, and boosters could have used to better adjudicate competing claims.

In many ways this is THE question I believe we have to answer as educators today. I responded that for past educators it seems to have been relatively easy to agree that colleges and universities should serve the public good, less easy to agree on the exact nature of that good, and harder still to agree on how to achieve it. Specifically, I think it is fair to say that both past and present Americans have agreed on many common goods plural, but that it has been much harder to agree on their ranking, and hence on which policies, both educational and political, best serve the nation. Additionally, my findings led me to conclude that it is nearly impossible for any one type of institution to do equally well by all types of students. The institutional pluralism of modern American higher education thus indeed seems best for a pluralistic nation. Yet if all these institutions seek to orient their students toward a common good—even if they do not agree on its exact nature—graduates will be primed for the process of democratic discussion.

But how can we know if students have internalized the moral vision their institutions have cast? I care about this question both as a historian and as an educator. I venture an answer in my book with respect to the institutional histories discussed there, but I also note that the question is notoriously difficult. I was therefore delighted to hear scholars at both conferences wrestling with the question of transmitting values. This theme was rarely the topic of an entire panel, but frequently appeared within individual papers. Collectively these papers indicate that attempts to transmit values to the next generation have often been mediated by educational institutions, religious institutions, or both. They have likewise been bound up in the tension between serving a particular religious community and serving the wider community:

Pete Cajka noted how the nineteenth-century U.S. Catholic school system sought both to preserve the faith and to form citizens. Benjamin Park noted how both Catholics and Mormons of that era shared a concern to stabilize American democracy by grounding Christian values in a religious hierarchy that could constitute a court of final appeal throughout time. I highlighted in my USIH presentation considerable concern within early twentieth-century mainline churches for how to retain the involvement of a new generation of college-educated women who were finding more opportunities for their talents outside the church. John Compton examined how J. Howard Pew’s father tightly controlled his education to inculcate in him a more conservative view of the relationship between Christianity and economics than characterized the bulk of his fellow Presbyterians. Daniel Williams noted how mid-twentieth century mainline apologists sought to defend Christianity not primarily for its own sake, but rather because they believed its values sustained the democratic political order.  Mario Rewers determined that students of the pioneer American studies classes actually valued and internalized their intended lessons in critical thinking. Elesha Coffman described how Margaret Mead wrestled with the problem of revising the baptismal liturgy of the Episcopal Church: if it changed too much, it wouldn't pass on the essence of the faith to the next generation, but if it didn’t change enough, that new generation would refuse to receive it. Matthew Bowman discussed how Robert Bellah’s concern with cults—very successful at transmitting their values and beliefs—focused on their separatist lack of interest in the common good. And Milton Gaither detailed what factors have correlated with successfully transmitting religious beliefs to the next generation and analyzed why the contemporary homeschooling movement did not actually succeed in doing so at a higher rate than average.

So where does all this leave me in my dual roles of historian seeking to understand changing American religious and moral values and educator seeking to instill in my students a desire to pursue the common good? I would say these conferences have challenged me to think more carefully in my own scholarship about how generational continuities and changes occur within educational and religious communities. And they have encouraged me to frame my teaching even more clearly around the pursuit of a common good throughout American history.

Perhaps there is hope: I stole an end-of-semester exercise from my colleague Elesha Coffman and asked students to list (anonymously) one thing they’ll do differently as a result of the class. Student answers included: “After this class, it will be easier for me to understand/appreciate others’ opinions,” “I cannot allow assumptions, fear, or ignorance to cloud my perspective,” “Be careful when discussing certain topics and always do my research first,” and, finally, “What I will do differently is analyze presidential candidates from a more unbiased, neutral perspective rather than putting them exclusively in the box of their political party.”
spacer

Religion at the U.S. Intellectual History Conference

Andrea L. Turpin

I am looking forward to the annual conference of the Society for U.S. Intellectual History (S-USIH) this coming weekend, October 26-29, 2017, at the Dallas/Plano Marriott at Legacy Town Center! (This Baylor professor got lucky with travel this year.)


One of the striking things about the program is how many papers related to American religion it contains. Indeed, this blog is exceptionally well represented. I am presenting, as are four fellow bloggers: Pete Cajka, Elesha Coffman, Lauren Turek, and blogmeister Cara Burnidge. Literally every time slot of panels save the very last one (which meets at 10am Sunday morning) has at least one paper on U.S. religious history--and more than one time slot has two entire panels on U.S. religion meeting simultaneously. There's a good mix of full panels on religious history and individual papers relating religion to a panel dedicated to a different main topic. Another encouraging sign of the vitality of the field is that the religious historians presenting at the conference span all career stages from graduate student to full professor.

Probably the most common themes in the papers are the connections between religious thought and politics/economics or women/gender. Other papers explore the intersection of religious thought with ideas about empire, education, and science. Judaism, Catholicism, and Protestantism--both conservative and liberal--are all reasonably well represented, with liberal Protestantism the most common. In the future, I would love to see more papers on the religious thought of people of color and religious thought beyond the boundaries of Christianity and Judaism.

I've listed below in bold the papers and panels explicitly featuring American religion. They give a good sense of the state of the field of the intersection of U.S. religious and intellectual history. Enjoy!

2017 USIH CONFERENCE SCHEDULE

Friday, October 27, 2017

8:00 AM – 9:40 AM                 Session I

“Religious Ideas: A State-of-the-Field Roundtable based on 19th and 20th Century American History” (roundtable)
Moderator:  Gale Kenny, Barnard College
Emily Conroy-Krutz, Michigan State University
Daniel Hummel, Harvard University
Peter Cajka, Notre Dame
Jacob Hiserman, Baylor University

“Humanisms in Twentieth Century American Culture” (panel)
 Chair/Comment:  Elisabeth Lasch-Quinn, Syracuse University
 Paul Murphy, Grand Valley State University, “Two Humanisms – Separate and Distinct, Conservative and Progressive – and the Belief in an American Mind”
 Stephen P. Weldon, University of Oklahoma, “Intellectuals and the Role of Liberal Religion as a Change Agent in 20th-Century America: The Example of American Humanism”
 Emily J. Griffin, University of Oklahoma, “Post-War Industrial America and the Shaping of the
Humanistic Worldviews of Kurt and Bernard Vonnegut”

 
“Modern Moral Causes in Context” (panel) (a/v)
Chair: Lilian Calles Barger, Independent Scholar
Chris Babits, University of Texas at Austin, “Curing the Fallen: Women Conversion Therapists, Freudianism, and Prayer in the 1970s and 1980s”
Alexander Steele, University of Minnesota, “Black Lives Matter: History, Memory, and the Politics of Dissent”
Adam Shapiro, “Does the March for Science Have an Intellectual History?”
Comment: audience

10:00 AM – 11:40 AM             Session II

“Annuit Coeptis: Forms of Civil Religion in the Midst of Crisis, 1953-2012” (roundtable)
Moderator: Ethan Schrum, Azusa Pacific University
Hilde Eliassen Restad, Bjørknes College
John D. Wilsey, Princeton University
James M. Patterson, Ave Maria University
Fred W. Beuttler, University of Chicago
Lauren F. Turek, Trinity University

1:30 PM – 3:10 PM                 Session III

“Religion and Nationalism in Early America” (panel)
Chair/Comment: Emily Conroy-Krutz, Michigan State University
Katherine Carté Engel, Southern Methodist University, “The Shallow Roots of American Religious Nationalism”
Ben Wright, University of Texas at Dallas, “Nationalism, Denominationalism, and the Benevolent Empire”
William Black, Rice University, “Cumberland Presbyterians and the Project of the Christian Nation”

3:30 PM – 5:10 PM                 Session IV

“Fundamentalists v. Feminists? Reevaluating the Role of Women and Gender in Conservative Protestant Political Engagement” (panel)
Chair/Comment: Daniel K. Williams, University of West Georgia
Andrea L. Turpin, Baylor University, “Women Between Fundamentalism and Modernism: Fusing Conservative Theology and Progressive Politics in the Presbyterian Church and the YWCA”
Elizabeth H. Flowers, Texas Christian University, “From Eve’s Curse to Eden’s Blessing: Submission, Complementarianism, and the Gendering of Inerrancy”
Karen K. Seat, University of Arizona, “The Symbiosis of Social and Fiscal Conservatives: Gender and Human Care in a Neoliberal World”

7:00 – 9:00 PM                        Friday Plenary Roundtable    

“Toward Democracy as Faith or Doubt”
Moderator: Christopher Cameron, University of North Carolina, Charlotte
Caleb McDaniel, Rice University
Amanda Porterfield, Florida State University
Manisha Sinha, University of Connecticut
Daniel Wickberg, University of Texas at Dallas
Respondent: James Kloppenberg, Harvard University

Saturday, October 28, 2017

8:00 AM – 9:40 AM                 Session V

“U.S. Women and Transatlantic Intellectual Cultures in the Nineteenth Century” (panel)
Chair/Comment: Sarah Gardner, Mercer University
Paul Gutacker, Baylor University, “Church Fathers and ‘Nursing Mothers’: Adaptations of Religious Historiography by Antebellum Women Historians”
Jonathan G. Koefoed, Belhaven University, “Harriet Beecher Stowe: A Transatlantic Romanticist”
Joel Iliff, Baylor University, “The Sable Wings of Skepticism: Antebellum Southern Women, German Thought, and Intellectual Crises of Faith”
Sara S. Frear, Houston Baptist University, “Seeing Farther: Mary Virginia Terhune Interprets Darwin for Her Readers”

“How to Make an ‘American Century’: Religion and the Shaping of the Modern Public Sphere” (panel)
Chair/Comment: Ray Haberski
Sara Georgini, Massachusetts Historical Society, “Making the Mapparium”
David Mislin, Temple University, “‘A Great Time to Be Alive’?: The Midcentury Protestant Establishment and the Memory of the Past”
Rachel Gordan, Brandeis University, “’Introduction to Judaism’ Literature”
 
10:00 AM – 11:40 AM             Session VI

“Markers of Memory in the Long 19th Century” (panel) (a/v)
Chair: Leslie A. Butler, Dartmouth College
Erin Bartram, University of Hartford, “’Jane’s mind desires intensely demonstration in all things’: Experiments in Imperfect Happiness in Antebellum America”
Lauren Davis, University of Texas at Dallas, “Free Women of Color and Counter-Domesticities of the Circum-Caribbean: Plaçage, Passing, Broken Marriages, and Religious Vocation as Alternatives to the Cult of True Womanhood in New Orleans, 1765-1865”
Nicolette Gable, College of William and Mary, “Memories of History in the Mauve Decade”
Ermine Algaier, Monmouth College, “Historicizing Alice’s ‘Valuable & Much Prized by W.J.’ Bibliography: A Nostalgic Reading”
Comment: audience

“Deep in the Mind of Texas: Unsung Texas Intellectuals, 1865-1965”
Chair/Comment: Robert H. Abzug, University of Texas at Austin
David Weinfeld, Virginia Commonwealth University, “Zionist, Pragmatist, Texan: The Case of Constance Pessels”
Karen Kossie-Chernyshev, Texas Southern University, “Lillian Jones Horace (1880-1965) and Zora Neale Hurston (1890-1960): Twin Towers of Black, Southern, Female Intellectual Engagement in Comparative/Contrastive Review”
Cynthia Morales, Texas State University, “Alonso S. Perales: Defender of His ‘Race’”

“In a Mirror, Darkly: Religion, Empire, America” (panel)
Chair/Comment: Philip Goff, Center for the Study of Religion and American Culture, IUPUI
Tracy Laevelle, Creighton University “A Fatal Experiment: Missionary Science and ‘Providential Colonialism’ in Nineteenth-Century Hawaii”
Cara Burnidge, University of Northern Iowa, “Woodrow Wilson’s ‘Spiritual Mediation’ and American Empire”
Raymond Haberski, Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis, “Competing Affections: The Challenge of Peace and Moral Debate Over Empire”

“Faith in an Anxious Age: Religious Thought in Mid-Twentieth-Century America” (panel)
Chair/Comment: Molly Worthen, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill
Daniel K. Williams, University of West Georgia, “Believing in God in the 1950s: Rational Defenses of Faith among Evangelicals, Mainline Protestants, and Catholics in the Early Postwar Years”
John W. Compton, Chapman University, “Holding the Vital Center: The National Council of Churches and the Postwar Welfare State”
Benjamin P. Leavitt, Baylor University, “Experiments in Education: Robert Lincoln Kelly, the Council of Church Boards of Education, and Religious Instruction in Early Twentieth-Century Colleges and Universities”

1:30 PM – 3:10 PM                 Session VII

“Feminist Disruptions in Theory” (panel)
Chair/Comment: Andrew Hartman, Illinois State University
Matthew Brown, University of Texas at Dallas, “William Moulton Marston’s Feminist-Scientific Critique of Freud”
Elesha Coffman, Baylor University, “Margaret Mead, Betty Friedan, and the Boundaries of Feminism”
Lilian Calles Barger, Independent Scholar, “From Subjectivity to Revolution: Radical Feminism and the Uses of Marcuse”
Gregory Jones-Katz, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, “The ‘Female’ School of Deconstruction and the Transformation of Feminism, 1969-1993”

3:30 PM – 5:10 PM                 Session VIII

“Democracy and Christianity in the American Political Arena” (panel)
Chair/Comment: Elesha Coffman, Baylor University
Benjamin E. Park, Sam Houston State University, “Self-Rule in a Godly Society: Antebellum Challenges to Protestant Democratic Culture”
Matthew Bowman, Henderson State University, “Robert Bellah and the Cults: Civic Religion, Liberal Protestantism, and Democracy in an Age of Anxiety”
Lily Santoro, Southwest Missouri State University, “Scientifically Creating Righteous and Fit Christian Citizens”

“Pluralism and Democracy in the Twentieth Century” (panel)
Chair/Comment: Anne Kornhauser
Andrew Seal, Yale University, “Pluralism and Its Problems: Reconstructing the Postwar Critique of Liberal Social Science”
Tom Arnold-Forster, Cambridge University, “Populism and Pluralism after the Scopes Trial”
Merve Fejzula, Cambridge University, “Cultural Pluralism and American Democracy in Black Diasporic Thought”

“Remembering and Forgetting that Old-Time Religion in the Age of Trump” (roundtable)
Moderator: L.D. Burnett
Jeff Sharlet, Dartmouth College
Randy R. Potts, freelance writer
Molly Worthen, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
Wassim Daghrir, University of Sousse

Sunday, October 29, 2017

8:00 AM – 9:40 AM                 Session IX

“Circulation of Ideas in Early Republic and Antebellum America”
Chair: Michael Landis, Tarleton State University
Rebecca Brenner, American University, “Mr. Jefferson’s Library & Mr. Madison’s War”
Samuel Davis, Temple University, “’Which all should labor to remove’: Colonization and Removal in the Old Northwest”
Daniel Roeber, Florida State University, “Delivering Religion at Reduced Rates: The Post Office and Religion in the Early Republic”
spacer

History Department Job Postings in U.S. Religious History

Andrea L. Turpin

It was the best of times, it was the worst of times. For job-seekers in U.S. religious history, Dickens seems to describe the history department market this year. The best of times: there is more than one tenure-track job specifically dedicated to U.S. religious history. The worst of times: no tenure-track job not specifically dedicated to this field lists it as a desired specialty. And it’s worth noting that most of the jobs in the field are at religiously affiliated institutions, albeit quite different ones. I would love to see history departments at a wide variety of institutions explicitly seeking coverage in this area. Still, I have to assume religious history remains a desirable subfield for at least some of these other jobs, considering that a mere 8 years ago the American Historical Association reported that religion was the largest subfield within the profession (with 7.7% of members listing it as one of three specialties).

So without further ado, here are the jobs (with links to the full posting) that would be of particular interest to readers of this blog:

TENURE-TRACK (AND TENURED)

1. Assistant or Associate Professor of History of American Christianity, Department of History and Ecumenics, Princeton Theological Seminary. A bit of online investigation turns up that the standard teaching load for the seminary is 2/2. It does not manage to turn up whether any sort of faith commitment or affiliation is required for the position, though PTS is affiliated with the mainline Presbyterian Church (USA), and the position calls for ability to teach Presbyterian history specifically. Application review begins October 6.



2. Assistant Professor of American Christianity, Department of History, Wheaton College (IL). Teaching load is 3/3. Wheaton requires adherence to a statement of faith and lifestyle expectations covenant. Application review begins October 9.

Side note: Wheaton is going to town. More advanced scholars in the field of U.S. religious history who can sign Wheaton’s statements would be eligible for two other positions currently advertised there: the Arthur F. Holmes Chair of Faith and Learning (applications reviewed immediately) and the Dean of Humanities and Theological Studies (applications reviewed September 30).

3. Assistant Professor of Muslims/Islam in North America, Joint Appointment between College of Liberal Arts (department flexible, with History listed as a desirable one) and Religious Studies Program, University of Minnesota-Twin Cities. Teaching load is 2/2. Application review begins October 15.

Bonus Position:

Come be my colleague! This job does not specifically ask for a specialty in U.S. religion, but many readers of this blog would find the Baylor history department an agreeable home as our Ph.D. program focuses on religion and culture.

4. Assistant Professor of U.S. South (19th Century/Antebellum Preferred), Department of History,
Baylor University. Teaching load is 2/2. Baylor hires faculty who are active in any faith community associated with the Judeo-Christian tradition, broadly defined. Application review begins November 1.

NON-TENURE-TRACK (AND VISITING)

OK, so these two aren’t in history departments, but they are too good not to mention, and would be welcoming to scholars trained in history departments because both institutions chose to list these positions on the AHA job website:

1. Postdoctoral Research Associates in Religion and Politics (in the U.S.), John C. Danforth Center on Religion and Politics, University of Washington-St. Louis. One year appointment renewable for second year. Teaches 1-2 courses/year. Three positions available. Application review begins January 8.

2. Research Associates and Visiting Faculty, Women’s Studies in Religion Program, Harvard Divinity School. Teaches 1 course/year. Five positions available. Application review begins October 15.

Since I’m a historian and all, I’ll cite my sources: the AHA job site, the Council for Christian Colleges & Universities (CCCU) job site, the history jobs wiki, and h-net. If I’ve missed any history department positions that specifically ask for U.S. religious history, please add them to the comments section!
spacer